research and direct work with government and criminal justice officials is clearly
needed to assess how these systems operate in practice across the OSCE region, and how they can be successfully reformed. The quantitative measurement
of criminal justice actors’ performance should be shifted away from the activities
of criminal justice actors (e.g. arrests and prosecutions), which do not reflect accurately the numbers of crimes being committed, on public safety and on public
satisfaction with the police.
72. In a Western European participating State, the last remaining police performance
targets were formally abolished in 2010.160 Despite this, a review in 2015 revealed
some forces were continuing to use targets. The review highlighted that the use
of targets encouraged police to underreport or misreport crimes, and to pressure
suspects into confessing to other crimes they had not committed.161 In the United
Kingdom more broadly, police performance is independently assessed by Her
Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS).
The HMICFRS commissions a survey each year on public perceptions of policing.
In 2018, the survey was conducted with over 17.000 members of the public, and
this constitutes a promising practice example on how to assess police performance without quota or performance target systems.162
Prosecutors
73. It is not just police who can be pressured to fulfil performance quotas. Pressures
to secure convictions inevitably affect the impartiality of prosecutors, who may
face personal consequences if quotas are not met, such as job loss or pay cuts.
One example from Eastern Europe shows that, conviction rates are used as the
central indicator to assess the performance not just of police, but also of prosecutors.163 Unlike the police, who have numerical targets to reach, prosecutors are
expected to obtain convictions in court, and are penalized if defendants are acquitted.164 This practice seems to persist despite the fact that the former Disciplinary
Statute of the Prosecutor’s Office from 1992 that stated that an acquittal is one of
the grounds for evaluating a prosecutor’s performance and initiating an investigation into their performance that could lead to disciplinary proceedings has been
160 HM Government, “Police reform: Theresa May’s speech to the National Policing Conference”
referring to England and Wales, (June 2010).
161 Chief Superintendent Irene Curtis, “The use of targets in policing”, (August 2015), pp 12–13.
162 HMICFRS, “Public perceptions of policing in England and Wales 2018”, (January 2019).
163 Questionnaire response Ukraine Without Torture (2019).
164 Ibid.
48
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents