92
234.
Moreover, in the report on its visit to Mexico, the SPT described the
use in some States of the so called “flagrancia equiparada”, used to justify mass arrests
of people not caught in flagrante and without ties or objects related to the offense, as a
strategy to criminalize social protest. The use of such arrests is made worse by the fact
that many of the detainees are unable to pay the high bail amounts demanded of
334
them. This provides an example of how the inability to make bail can be used as a tool
to repress certain groups.
235.
The Commission considers that States must ensure that bail
mechanisms observe principles of material equality and that they do not constitute a
form of discrimination against people unable to come up with the amounts set. In cases
in which the inability of the accused to pay has been established, courts must use other
methods to ensure appearance at trial that do not entail deprivation of liberty. In
accordance with the principle of presumption of innocence, in no instance may bail
constitute or include reparation for the harm caused by the offense with which the
accused is charged.
236.
With respect to the amount of bail, the European Court has
established that it should be determined in light of the accused’s situation, his financial
capacity (possessions), and his relationship to the person or entity acting as guarantor;
and that in all events, the nature of such bail should be such that it will act as a sufficient
335
deterrent to dispel any intent on his part to abscond. All these are subjective factors
that will depend on the specific situation and capacities of the person facing trial. The
European Court has also stated that the mere absence of a fixed residence does not give
336
rise to a danger of flight.
237.
House arrest is another measure that requires appropriate regulation
and supervision. At the hearing on the Situation of Human Rights of Women Deprived of
Liberty in Bolivia, it was noted that house arrest prevents low-income women from
pursuing economic activities outside the home to provide for their sustenance and that
of their families. Moreover, when women are placed under the oversight of a police
officer, they have to provide the officer with a place to sleep, food, and transportation
337
Challenges of this kind in the
to their homes from the location he indicates.
implementation of this measure have also been observed in other countries of the
region.
334
UN, Subcommittee for the Prevention of Torture, Report on the Visit of the SPT to Mexico,
CAT/OP/MEX/1, published May 27, 2009, para. 208.
335
ECHR, Case of Neumeister v. Austria (Application No. 1936/63), Plenary of the Court, Judgment
of June 27, 1968, para. 14.
336
ECHR, Case of Sulaoja v. Estonia (Application No. 55939/00), Fourth Section of the Court,
Judgment of February 12, 2005, para. 64.
337
IACHR, Situation of Human Rights of Women Deprived of Liberty in Bolivia, 147th regular period
of sessions, organized by the Legal Office for Women (OJM), Latin American and Caribbean Committee for the
Defense of Women’s Rights (CLADEM), Center for Justice and International Law (CEJIL), March 15, 2013.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents