Because of low salaries and hard working conditions, qualified personnel do not come to work in IAD TDFs.
Therefore, TDFs are left to recruit newcomers. In one of the IADs, a driver who used to work in that IAD was
appointed a Head of the TDF.266
During an interview one of the Heads of IAD told the following about the recruitment process: “We do prepare
staff for working at TDFs and district IABs. However, because we report to the internal affairs department…,
all staff members are appointed from there. These people have no experience, practical skills or knowledge.
It takes a lot of time for them to get used to our work. As a consequence, the work of the whole district IAB is
affected. Officially we are not entitled to object to any candidates appointed.” 267
High personnel turnover is in inherent to all IAD TDFs. For instance, 52.9% of heads of IAB TDFs have
worked in their positions for less than one year; each fourth of them has up to two years of working experience
in this position, and 23.5% – 3 years and more.
Similar situation is with TDF personnel.
Diagram 30.
Working Experience of TDF Staff Members.
TDF personnel rarely take skills improvement courses.
Medical examination of members of staff varies from TDF to TDF. Members of some TDFs undergo medical
examination twice a year, i.e., every six months, and others do it only once a year. 268
Since TDF personnel have to work with a very difficult cohort of people and they are permanently under stress,
it appears crucial to create a wide network of psychological service represented in each territorial department
of the Interior Ministry. Specialists will train TDF personnel to use self-management techniques and will help
manage stressful situations.
The monitoring team would like to emphasize the importance of improving legal consciousness of officials
and regular personnel of IAD TDFs in the area of preventing torture and ill-treatment.
One of the reasons for this concern and the resulting recommendation is statements of some IAB officials.
Example: Head of a TDF said that it is impossible to succeed in investigation without torture.”269
Example: Head of a TDF said to the monitoring team when seeing them off: “It is not a big deal that
law enforcement members beat especially dangerous criminals.”270
266
267
268
269
270
Monitoring Report No. 20/16-18/Н/1.0.
Monitoring Report No. 5/11/О/1.0.
Monitoring Report No. 8/5/П/1.0; 6/5-6-9/П/1.0.; 1/3-9/П/1.0.
Monitoring Report No. 6/5-6-9/О/1.0.
Monitoring Report No. 8/3-7/Н/1.0.
82
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents