In Kazakhstan, the ODIHR also reviewed new amendments to the law on defence lawyers that concern reform of access to the bar, disciplinary proceedings, and the organizational structure of the bar. During the Supplementary Human Dimension Meeting on
the Role of Defence Lawyers in Guaranteeing a Fair Trial, in November 2005, a number
of recommendations were made with respect to bar reform that could be implemented in Kazakhstan. The ODIHR plans to organize an international conference on reform
of the bar in Kazakhstan in 2006.
In Armenia, the ODIHR followed the implementation of the new law on advocates and
also monitored the unification of two former bodies into the newly established Chamber of Advocates.
Professional development
The ODIHR also encourages the creation of continuing legal education programmes
that allow legal professionals to regularly update their professional knowledge and improve their skills.
In 2005, the ODIHR worked with defence lawyers in Kazakhstan on improving the professionalism of bar members. A group of Kazakh trainers who completed an ODIHR
training programme in 2004 conducted more than 90 hours of seminars to improve
the professional legal skills of their less-experienced colleagues in the Almaty City Collegium of Advocates. In Kyrgyzstan, the ODIHR provided support to the Youth Human
Rights Group, a national NGO that implements an advanced training course for lawyers on the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Twenty-five lawyers will
complete this programme in 2006.
Responding to a request from the Armenian Prosecutor General’s Office, the ODIHR
carried out a training session for a group of Armenian prosecutors in November 2005
on dealing with domestic violence. The seminar featured a prominent expert from the
English Crown Prosecution Service. In 2006, the ODIHR will conduct another training
session for Armenian prosecutors on prosecuting cases of sexual assault.
Trial observation
Trial-observation programmes can be instrumental to promoting the right to a fair trial.
The information gathered by observers often points to the most pressing reform needs
and may provide a basis for reform discussions. In individual cases, the presence of
observers in the courtroom may encourage the court and the parties to adhere to the
procedural rules more vigorously.
When the ODIHR organized the first OSCE Inter-Mission Trial Observation Meeting in
2002, trial observation was a relatively new activity for OSCE field operations, conducted primarily in the countries of South-Eastern Europe. A wealth of experience has been
gained by those trial observers, who can offer experience to others who have begun to
conduct trial observation in other parts of the OSCE region. The ODIHR organized two
meetings in 2005 to provide such opportunities to exchange experiences and lessons
learned. The fourth Inter-Mission Trial Observation Meeting was held in Sarajevo in the
fall, with staff from 12 OSCE field missions attending. A smaller meeting followed this in
Zagreb that was dedicated to observation of war-crimes cases.
OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions
and Human Rights
Rule of Law
Tel.: +48 22 520 0600
Al. Ujazdowskie 19
Fax: +48 22 520 0605
00-557 Warsaw
E-mail: ruleoflaw@odihr.pl
Poland
www.osce.org/odihr
May 2006