Tool 2: Policing and Gender
In many countries discrimination against LGBTI people increases their risk of coming into
contact with the criminal justice system. Being thrown out of home and the resultant
increased risk of homelessness, for instance, can put people in conflict with the law, as can
trauma suffered as a result of sustained and/or intense discrimination and violence.12 They
can then suffer the consequences of discriminatory attitudes within juries or among judges.
In countries where homosexuality is criminalized, LGBTI persons who are victims of a crime
can be reluctant to seek justice. In Lebanon, for instance, while homosexuality is not explicitly
outlawed, elements of the Penal Code criminalize same-sex intercourse. This deters LGBTI
people from reporting rape for fear of prosecution and incarceration.13 And while people
of diverse sexual orientations and gender identities and expressions have tended to be
particularly vulnerable to atrocities committed during armed conflict, transitional justice
mechanisms have generally ignored their experiences.14
Integrating a gender perspective is important for the justice sector to protect the rights of
LGBTI people, facilitate their access to justice and, ultimately, help reduce violence against
them.
Intersectionality*
Recognizing that men and women, including LGBTI people, are not homogeneous groups,
it is necessary for any work on gender and justice to consider how gender intersects with
race, class, age, ethnicity, religion, indigeneity, disability and other demographic identifiers
in different places and in different times.15
The concept of intersectionality refers to the interaction between two or more forms
of discrimination or systems of subordination, such as racism, patriarchy or economic
disadvantage. An intersectional analysis often shows that the dynamics of exclusion,
inequality and violence are intensified when one or more of these systems of subordination
intersect: for instance, when a person is also socio-economically marginalized, a member of
an indigenous community or ethnic minority group, displaced, LGBTI, has disabilities and/
or is an orphan.
2.4 Laws are often discriminatory and/or applied in a
discriminatory manner
Many countries maintain discriminatory laws concerning GBV, domestic violence, land
ownership, marriage, child custody, inheritance, employment and sexual orientation. The
following is but a selection of examples.
Ê GBV laws commonly exclude certain victims. For example, in some countries laws
concerning rape only recognize that females can be raped, only recognize males as
perpetrators, do not recognize rape within marriage and/or do not recognize same-sex
rape. Others have a long list of mitigating circumstances for rape (e.g. where it might
be considered a “crime of passion”).
Ê In certain countries domestic violence and intimate-partner violence as forms of GBV
are not criminalized.
Ê Many forms of GBV are not effectively criminalized in law and practice, including
transphobic and homophobic violence and online abuse (see case study 1).
Ê Where a law is not overtly discriminatory, “neutral” application of the law can have
discriminatory effects on women. For instance, in Cameroon, statutory land tenure
legislation appears gender neutral but has gendered effects. The patriarchal system
of inheritance means that the law leaves women vulnerable to being dispossessed of
their land by family members when their spouse dies.16
* Intersectionality is discussed
in more detail in Tool 1, and
conducting intersectional
gender analysis is discussed
in Tool 15.
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents