The EU Torture Trade Regulation offers a good model dividing the items into two categories:
i
“prohibited” goods that are inherently abusive in nature, and;
ii
“controlled” goods that can have a legitimate law enforcement or other use but need to be subject
to trade controls in order to avoid their employment in torture, other ill-treatment or the death
penalty.
Law enforcement weapons and devices should never be supplied to recipients who are likely
to use them for torture, other ill-treatment or other serious human rights violations. Although
this principle is already incorporated in many policies of individual states and certain regional
organizations, the lack of international regulation is a substantive loophole in practice that needs to
be urgently closed. The current failure of states to collectively prohibit the trade in equipment which
is inherently abusive, and effectively control other equipment which is often abused, poses a threat
to human rights around the world.
Amnesty International and the Omega Research Foundation are calling on all states, including Global
Alliance Members, to introduce comprehensive measures to tackle the trade in “tools of torture” by:
• Adopting regulations to ban the production of, and trade in, inherently abusive law enforcement
equipment and related training;
• Adopting trade regulations, establishing strict control measures, incorporating human rights-based
risk assessment, on the transfer of law enforcement equipment that could be easily abused for
torture and other ill-treatment;
• Agree regional and international mechanisms to regulate the trade in “tools of torture” in a
harmonized manner which incorporate a transparent system for reporting and information sharing.
THE CURRENT FAILURE OF STATES
TO COLLECTIVELY PROHIBIT THE TRADE
IN EQUIPMENT WHICH IS INHERENTLY
ABUSIVE, AND EFFECTIVELY CONTROL OTHER
EQUIPMENT WHICH IS OFTEN ABUSED, POSES
A THREAT TO HUMAN RIGHTS AROUND THE WORLD.
COMBATING TORTURE: THE NEED FOR COMPREHENSIVE REGULATION OF LAW ENFORCEMENT EQUIPMENT
Amnesty International | Omega Research Foundation
3