and specific for electric current trauma. Absence of these
specific changes in a biopsy specimen does not mitigate
against a diagnosis of electric shock torture, and judicial
authorities must not be permitted to make such an
assumption. Unfortunately, if a court requests a petitioner
alleging electric shock torture to submit to a biopsy for
confirmation of the allegations, refusal to consent to the
procedure or a negative result is bound to have a prejudicial impact on the court. Furthermore, clinical experience
with biopsy diagnosis of torture-related electrical injury is
limited, and the diagnosis can usually be made with confidence from the history and physical examination alone.
suspension torture. In the acute period, oedema, fluid collection on and around the shoulder joint, lacerations and
haematomas of the rotator cuffs can be observed by ultrasound. Re-examination with ultrasound and finding that
the evidence in the acute period disappears over time
strengthen the diagnosis. In such cases, MRI, scintigraphy
and other radiological examinations should be carried out
together, and their correlation should be examined. Even
without positive results from other examinations, ultrasound findings alone are adequate to prove suspension
torture.
(c) Computerized tomography
This procedure is, therefore, one that should be done in
a clinical research setting and not promoted as a diagnostic standard. In giving informed consent for biopsy, the
person must be informed of the uncertainty of the results
and permitted to weigh the potential benefit against the
impact upon an already traumatized psyche.
CT is excellent for imaging soft tissue and bone. However, MRI is better for soft tissue than bone. MRI may
detect an occult fracture before it can be imaged by either
routine radiographs or scintigraphy. Use of open scanners
and sedation may alleviate anxiety and claustrophobia,
which are prevalent among torture survivors. CT is also
excellent for diagnosing and evaluating fractures, especially temporal and facial bones. Other advantages
include alignment and displacement of fragments, especially spinal, pelvic, shoulder and acetabular fractures. It
cannot identify bone bruising. CT with and without intravenous infusion of a contrast agent should be the initial
examination for acute, sub-acute and chronic central
nervous system (CNS) lesions. If the examination is
negative, equivocal or does not explain the survivor’s
CNS complaints or symptoms, proceed to MRI. CT with
bone windows and a pre- and post-contrast examination
should be the initial examination for temporal bone fractures. Bone windows may demonstrate fractures and
ossicular disruption. The pre-contrast examination may
demonstrate fluid and cholesteatoma. Contrast is recommended because of the common vascular anomalies that
occur in this area. For rhinorrhea, injection of a contrast
agent into the spinal canal should follow a temporal bone.
MRI may also demonstrate the tear responsible for leakage of the fluid. When rhinorrhea is suspected, a CT of the
face with soft tissue and bone windows should be performed. Then a CT should be obtained after a contrast
agent is injected into the spinal canal.
(a) Rationale for biopsy
There has been extensive laboratory research measuring the effects of electric shocks on the skin of anaesthetized pigs.b,c,d,e,f,g This work has shown that there are histologic findings specific to electrical injury that can be
established by microscopic examination of punch biopsies of the lesions. However, further discussion of this
research, which may have significant clinical application,
is beyond the scope of this publication. The reader is
referred to the footnote references for additional information.
Few cases of electric shock torture of humans have
been studied histologically.h,i,j,k Only in one case, where
b H. K. Thomsen and others, “Early epidermal changes in heat and
electrically injured pigskin: a light microscopic study”, Forensic
Science International, vol. 17 (1981), pp. 133-143.
c Ibid., “The effect of direct current, sodium hydroxide and
hydrochloric acid on pig epidermis: a light microscopic and electron
microscopic study”, Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Immunol. Scand, vol. 91
(1983), pp. 307-316.
d H. K. Thomsen, “Electrically induced epidermal changes: a
morphological study of porcine skin after transfer of low-moderate
amounts of electrical energy”, dissertation (University of Copenhagen,
F.A.D.L., 1984), pp. 1-78.
e T. Karlsmark and others, “Tracing the use of torture: electrically
induced calcification of collagen in pigskin”, Nature, vol. 301 (1983),
pp. 75-78.
f Ibid., “Electrically induced collagen calcification in pigskin: a
histopathologic and histochemical study”, Forensic Science
International, vol. 39 (1988), pp. 163-174.
g T. Karlsmark, “Electrically induced dermal changes: a
morphological study of porcine skin after transfer of low to moderate
amounts of electrical energy”, dissertation, University of Copenhagen,
Danish Medical Bulletin, vol. 37 (1990), pp. 507-520.
h L. Danielsen and others, “Diagnosis of electrical skin injuries: a
review and a description of a case”, American Journal of Forensic
Medical Pathology, vol.12 (1991), pp. 222-226.
i F. Öztop and others, “Signs of electrical torture on the skin”,
Treatment and Rehabilitation Center Report 1994 (Human Rights
Foundation of Turkey), vol. 11 (1994), pp. 97-104.
j L. Danielsen, T. Karlsmark, H. K. Thomsen, “Diagnosis of skin
lesions following electrical torture”, Rom. J. Leg. Med., vol. 5 (1997),
pp. 15-20.
k H. Jacobsen, “Electrically induced deposition of metal on the
human skin”, Forensic Science International, vol. 90 (1997), pp. 85-92.
(d) Magnetic resonance imaging
MRI is more sensitive than CT in detecting CNS
abnormalities. The time course of CNS haemorrhage is
divided into immediate, hyperacute, acute, sub-acute and
chronic phases and CNS haemorrhage has ranges that correlate with imaging characteristics of the haemorrhage.
Thus, the imaging findings may allow estimation of the
timing of head injuries and correlation to alleged
incidents. CNS haemorrhage may completely resolve or
produce sufficient haemosiderin deposits for the CT to be
positive even years later. Haemorrhage in soft tissue,
especially in muscle, usually resolves completely, leaving
no trace, but, in rare cases, it can ossify. This is called
heterotrophic bone formation or Myositis ossificans and is
detectable with CT.
2.
Biopsy of electric shock injury
Electric shock injuries may, but do not necessarily,
exhibit microscopic changes that are highly diagnostic
62
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents