prolonged periods. The CPT recommends
that, in the interest of the prevention of
ill-treatment, persons remanded in custody be promptly transferred to a prison
establishment and only be returned to
a police detention facility when there is
absolutely no other alternative and for
the shortest time possible.
63. As regards prisons, the CPT’s delegation received no allegations of physical illtreatment of prisoners by staf at Szeged
Prison or at the Central Prison Hospital
and the Unit for HIV-positive prisoners in
Tököl; however, several such allegations
were received at Somogy County Remand
Prison in Kaposvár and Sopronkőhida
Prison. A number of accounts of verbal
abuse of a racist nature and disrespectful
remarks were also heard in the various
establishments visited. Furthermore, in
some of the establishments visited, interprisoner violence was an issue. The CPT
also expresses serious doubts about the
efectiveness of investigations into complaints of ill-treatment by prison staf.
Hungarian authorities state that the current organisational system has brought
positive results, such as the promotion
of a unifed training system in the area of
law enforcement and cost-efectiveness
through the unifcation of technology
and equipment.
The CPT also expresses serious concerns
about the lack of efective action to combat overcrowding (which has doubled
since the 2009 visit and stood at 144% of
the ofcial prison capacity in 2013). The
CPT urges the authorities not to limit their
response to a “balancing” programme
whereby the Prison Service re-allocates
prisoners nationwide to ensure a similar
degree of overcrowding in each prison.
Such an approach is inefective and does
not address the root causes of overcrowding in prisons.
In the light of these fndings, the CPT
recommends that the national authorities redouble their eforts to combat
ill-treatment by prison staf, review the
system for investigating allegations of
ill-treatment in order to make it more
efective and protect the integrity of
all prisoners, including against other
inmates.
Concerning the regime, many prisoners
were still locked up in their cells for
23 hours a day, with little to occupy
them. The CPT recommends that programmes of purposeful activities, tailored
to the individual needs of the inmates,
be further developed. In their response,
the Hungarian authorities indicate that
particular importance is being paid to
this issue, including development of
training, education and employment
opportunities, and refer to the recent
signifcant increase in the employment
rate of prisoners.
Since 2010, the responsibility for the
administration of prisons has been
placed, together with the police, under
the authority of the Ministry of the
Interior. The CPT is concerned that this
approach may call into question the
specifcities of the respective tasks of
police and prison ofcers; it is also not
in line with the European Prison Rules.
The Committee invites the Hungarian
authorities to reconsider their position
on this matter. In their response, the
The CPT’s report also notes that eforts
have been made to improve the situation
of prisoners serving lengthy sentences at
Szeged Prison. For example, the Special
Regime Unit for these inmates aimed
to function as a genuine induction unit
and the delegation’s fndings indicate
that the Unit helped many of those
prisoners to come to terms with their
sentences, in particular those serving
actual life sentences. However, as regards
prisoners sentenced to life imprisonment
General Report of the CPT, 2013-2014 ► Page 32
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents