Deputy Minister of Internal Afairs and
the Deputy Minister of Justice, as well as
with senior ofcials of these Ministries.
Consultations were also held with the
Prosecutor General.
The high-level talks were organised in
the aftermath of police interventions
on 30 November 2013 at Independence
Square (“Maidan”) and on 1 December
2013 on Bankova Street in Kyiv. The main
objective of the talks was to obtain details
about all the persons deprived of their
liberty in the context of the then ongoing
demonstrations in Kyiv and the investigations which had been initiated following
complaints of detained demonstrators
about ill-treatment by law enforcement
ofcials. In addition, discussions were
held on the action taken by the relevant
authorities to prevent future instances
of ill-treatment and/or excessive use of
force during police interventions.
23. On 24 September 2014, representatives of the CPT participated in a
round table in Moscow organised by
the Ministry of Justice of the Russian
Federation in co-operation with the CPT.
The event was held following the publication of the Committee’s reports on
two visits to the country, namely the 2011
ad hoc visit to the North Caucasian region
of the Russian Federation and the 2012
periodic visit to the country. It provided
a useful opportunity to meet and discuss
issues of common interest with Maxim
Travnikov, Deputy Minister of Justice,
and senior ofcials from the Ministries of
Justice, the Interior and Foreign Afairs, as
well as from the Federal Service for the
Execution of Sentences, the Investigative
Committee, the Federal Drug Control
Service, the Ofce of the Human Rights
Commissioner and the Council of Public
Monitoring Commissions.
The discussions focused on the implementation by the Russian authorities of
General Report of the CPT, 2013-2014 ► Page 14
the recommendations made by the CPT
in the past: in particular those referred to
in the two aforementioned visit reports.
Special attention was paid to the treatment of persons deprived of their liberty
by law enforcement agencies and the situation of inmates held in pre-trial detention, as well as to the provision of health
care in penitentiary establishments and
the conditions of detention of prisoners
sentenced to life imprisonment. The issue
of investigations into allegations of illtreatment by law enforcement and prison
ofcers was also addressed in detail.
Plenary meetings and
activities of subgroups
24. The CPT held four one-week plenary
meetings during the period covered by
this General Report, in November 2013
and in March, July and November 2014.
A total of 22 visit reports were adopted
by the Committee at these meetings.
25. At its March 2014 plenary meeting,
the Committee had an exchange of
views with judges of the European
Court of Human Rights, including the
Court’s President, Dean Spielmann. The
exchange of views focused on three
topics: (a) the extra-territorial application
of the European Convention on Human
Rights and its implication on the CPT’s
activities, (b) recent developments in the
Court’s case-law as regards the “efectiveness” of investigations, in particular concerning the criterion of “independence”,
and (c) prisoners sentenced to “actual” life
imprisonment (i.e. without the possibility
of conditional release).
26. In view of the infux of new members
in 2014 and in order to refresh the skills of
all members, a half-day during the plenary
meetings in July and November 2014 was
devoted to training in the techniques of
visiting police stations and psychiatric
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents