Information is also provided on the measures being taken or under consideration
to implement the CPT’s recommendations concerning inter-prisoner violence,
and to enhance the programme of activities in prison. The authorities also state
that they have no objection to reducing
the maximum duration of disciplinary
confnement from 21 to 14 days but that
this will require legislative amendments.
82. As regards Monsanto High Security
Prison, where prisoners were confned
alone in their cells for some 21 hours
a day, recommendations are made to
develop the range of purposeful activities
and to promote better contacts between
staf and prisoners. Further, the authorities are again requested to institute rigorous safeguards concerning the placement of prisoners, and any extension
thereof, in the high-security estate.
The report also invites the Portuguese
authorities to phase out the carrying of
truncheons by custodial staf in detention areas at both Lisbon Central and
Monsanto Prisons, stating that it is not
conducive to promoting positive relations between staf and inmates. In parallel, steps should be taken to upgrade the
skills of prison staf in handling high-risk
situations without using unnecessary
force, in particular by providing regular
training in averting crises and defusing
tension and in the use of safe methods
of manual control and restraint.
83. In the course of the May 2013 visit,
the CPT’s delegation also examined in
detail the investigation into a serious
allegation of ill-treatment of a person by a
National Republican Guard (GNR) ofcer,
which it had raised in the report on the
2012 visit to Portugal. The Portuguese
authorities had been requested to carry
out an investigation into this case; however, the response of the authorities
appeared to indicate that no efective
investigation had in fact been carried
out. The 2013 report highlights a series
of defciencies undermining the efectiveness of the investigation of this case,
notably as regards the promptness,
thoroughness and independence of the
investigation. Further, it raises concerns
as to the fow of information between the
GNR, the Inspectorate General of Home
Afairs (IGAI) and the Public Prosecutor’s
Ofce. In their extensive response, the
Portuguese authorities concur with the
CPT’s fndings concerning the investigation into this specifc case and refer to
the steps being taken to ensure that the
Public Prosecutor’s Ofce and the relevant inspectorates are informed directly
of any allegation of ill-treatment in the
future.
Report and response
published in November 2013,
CPT/Inf (2013) 35 and CPT/Inf (2013) 36
Report on the periodic visit
to the Russian Federation in
May/June 2012 and response
of the Russian authorities
(torture and ill-treatment by law enforcement ofcials, impunity, safeguards against
ill-treatment, conditions of detention in law
enforcement establishments and prisons)
84. In the course of the visit, the CPT’s
delegation assessed progress made
since previous visits and in particular
the extent to which the Committee’s recommendations have been implemented
in the areas of police custody and pretrial detention in Moscow and Leningrad
Regions as well as in the Republics of
Bashkortostan and Tatarstan. The delegation also visited a closed-type prison
(t’yurma), in Vladimir Region, and paid
a follow-up visit to Yagul Strict-Regime
Colony No. 1 in the Republic of Udmurtia.
Publication highlights
► Page 41
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents