Section one Context
The Public Services Reform (Inspection and
Monitoring of Prisons) (Scotland) Order 2015
replaced prison visiting committees with a
new system of monitors under the auspices
of HMIPS, and gave responsibility to HM
Chief Inspector of Prisons for Scotland to
appoint prison monitoring coordinators.44 In a
similar vein, the Harris Review recommended
that the responsibility for the oversight
and funding of the IMBs should transfer to
HMI Prisons.45 The NPM welcomes explicit
references to OPCAT and the visiting role of
the UN SPT introduced in the Public Services
Reform (Inspection and Monitoring of
Prisons) (Scotland) Order 2015.46
The NPM also welcomes the explicit
reference to OPCAT (and the Care Quality
Commission’s role as part of the NPM) in the
new Mental Health Act Code of Practice.
A Joint Ministerial Council Communiqué
was agreed by political leaders and
representatives of the UK and the overseas
territories in December 2014. This included
a commitment to extend core UN human
rights conventions to the territories, but
no explicit reference to OPCAT which
was disappointing.47 The sharing of best
practice on prison management between
the overseas territories and the UK is to be
welcomed, but falls short of the standards
required by OPCAT.
In July 2014, HM Chief Inspector of Prisons
(England and Wales) wrote to the then
Secretary of State for Defence expressing
disappointment with the announcement that
the Baha Mousa inquiry recommendation
that HMI Prisons should conduct independent
inspection of the UK’s Afghanistan detention
facilities was no longer necessary. While the
UK presence in Afghanistan was winding
down, the letter expressed the importance
that the principle of independent inspection
of UK-controlled places of detention overseas
should be established and applied on future
occasions where this occurs. HMI Prisons
actively sought the inclusion of powers to
inspect military detention into the five-yearly
Armed Forces Bill, in order to put existing
arrangements on a statutory footing. As
this report was being finalised, HMI Prisons
was told that the government no longer
intended to put the inspection of military
detention onto a statutory footing, which
was disappointing.
44 At: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ssi/2015/39/contents/made (accessed 14/10/15).
45 The Harris Review (2015), Changing prisons, saving lives: report of the independent review into self-inflicted deaths in
custody of 18-24 year olds.
46 This is the second reference to OPCAT in NPM members’ statutes, the first being in the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act
(93).
47 At: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/388001/JMC_Communique_FINAL.pdf
(accessed 14/10/15).
19
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents