A/HRC/40/59/Add.2
very low wages. In the same vein, activities aiming to facilitate the reintegration of prisoners
after their release were reported to be very restricted.
58.
The Special Rapporteur would like emphasize that opportunities to engage in work,
education and recreation are of critical importance not only for the mental, emotional and
physical well-being of inmates, but also for their successful reintegration after their release.
H.
Violent and invasive searches
59.
In some places, inmates reported having been subjected to violent, invasive and/or
humiliating searches, which have resulted in an atmosphere of fear among the detainees.
During his visit to Unit IV of the Ezeiza federal prison, in pavilion 11 the Special Rapporteur
was alarmed to witness the sudden deployment of heavily equipped male and female security
personnel in protective riot gear throughout the wing he was visiting, and was informed that
this constituted the standard security set-up and procedures to conduct the daily head count
of the female prisoners. According to inmates, in March 2018, the prison service had also
reportedly used excessive force on a group of women in that complex who had been
protesting about not having received their salary.
60.
In all the institutions visited, inmates also reported having been subjected to routine
body searches whenever they exited and re-entered the establishment, such as before and
after court sessions, during visits by family members, and even when moving from one
section of the facility to another. Some inmates reported strip-searches and body-cavity
searches, including having to bend and being frisked. The population most at risk of being
stigmatized or humiliated by searches are women and lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and
intersex persons.
61.
Overall, the Special Rapporteur would like to recall that searches must never be more
intrusive than necessary and must be conducted in a respectful manner, with due regard to
factors such as gender and age. Overly intrusive or humiliating searches with the simple aim
of intimidating or harassing a detainee can amount to ill-treatment.
I.
Punitive transfers to remote locations
62.
Many inmates complained that they were imprisoned far from their families, that the
resulting lack of family contact was further aggravated by excessively short, sporadic visits
and procedures that their families found humiliating. The Special Rapporteur expresses
concern over allegations received that transfers to remote places of detention were used as a
form of punishment or reprisal against certain detainees. He would like to stress that such
punitive transfers not only are likely to severely affect the health and well-being of the
inmates concerned and their families, but also may well amount to cruel, inhuman or
degrading punishment.
J.
Corruption and inter-prisoner violence
63.
The Special Rapporteur received numerous allegations of corruption among prison
staff, involving, for example, the extortion of money in exchange for better detention
conditions or protection from inmate violence or, conversely, punitive transfers inside
institutions to wings occupied by more violent inmates.
64.
Prison staff reportedly also often enabled the smuggling into places of detention of
drugs and cell phones, which were subsequently confiscated and sold back to the prisoners.
Prison guards were also frequently alleged to “confiscate” for their own purposes, or for the
purpose of resale to the inmates, food, hygiene articles and other items allocated for free by
the authorities or provided by families. Corrupt practices such as these are reportedly
facilitated by the fact that access to food rations, family and conjugal visits, and education
and work programmes are largely subject to the discretion of the guards.
65.
The Special Rapporteur notes with great concern that an apparently pervasive system
of corruption often deprives inmates nationwide of the most basic items required for their
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents