118 | Towards the Closure of Guantanamo
care” in which the individual is constantly monitored. According to the lawyer for
Fouzi Al Awda, a former Guantanamo detainee who is part of the program, Mr. Al
Awda was required to surrender his passport and check in weekly with local police.
His internet usage, religious instruction, social networks, financial affairs, and visits
to local mosques will also be reportedly monitored. 347
287. The IACHR reiterates that Guantanamo detainees have been unlawfully detained for
more than a decade, without charge or trial, and an inter-agency review has decided
not to prosecute many of them but instead to authorize their transfer. Therefore,
any such restrictions imposed by the United States or by the receiving country
would constitute an arbitrary interference with the enjoyment of the detainees’
human rights. The IACHR is also disturbed by the reported treatment that U.S.
authorities give to detainees during transfer. According to a statement made by the
defense counsel of Abu Dhiad, a former Syrian detainee who was resettled in
Uruguay together with five others on December 7, 2014. During the flight the
detainees were reportedly handcuffed and shackled, their eyes and ears were
covered and they wore thick gloves to reduce all contact with their environment. 348
288. Once a detainee has been cleared for transfer, the U.S. authorities have no basis to
continue treating him as a suspected terrorist. Therefore, cleared detainees should
be housed separately from the rest of the prisoners, should have ample access to
counsel and family members, and should not be subjected to the regime applicable
to the rest of the prison population. Detainees cleared for transfer should be treated
as persons who have never been charged –which is what they are-- whom the
authorities have no legitimate interest in detaining. The only reason they are still at
Guantanamo is that they are waiting for a third country to receive them. For these
reasons, transfers should be carried out with full respect for the detainees’ rights to
liberty and to personal integrity. Upon arrival, former detainees should not be
subjected to any unlawful restriction in the receiving country.
289. The Inter-American Commission calls for the repeal of the NDAA provisions that
prohibit the transfer of Guantanamo detainees to the United States. Transfers to the
United States should be allowed for purposes of emergency medical treatment, trial,
or in cases of detainees cleared for transfer who would be at risk in their home
country and who are unable or unwilling to go to a third country. Even though
restrictions on transfers imposed by Congress have been a significant obstacle in
the closure of the detention facility, the Executive branch has the responsibility to
explore all potential avenues. This not only includes diplomatic negotiations but
also the search for opportunities within the existing statutory limitations, such as
interpreting in a flexible manner the requirements imposed by the NDAA, an aspect
that will be developed below.
347
348
Vice News, Life After Guantanamo: The Rehabilitation Program for Kuwait’s Released Inmate, November 10,
2014. Available at: https://news.vice.com/article/life-after-guantanamo-the-rehabilitation-program-forkuwaits-released-inmate
La Republica, Los 6 ex reclusos quieren quedarse en Uruguay, December 6, 2014. Available at:
http://www.republica.com.uy/reclusos-en-uruguay/493003/
Organization of American States | OAS
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents