A/HRC/4/40/Add.4
page 24
100. In order to strengthen the control over the legality of detention at all stages of the
criminal justice process:
(a)
All institutions in which persons are detained need to maintain complete and
transparent records showing the legal basis for detention. In particular, police stations
need a single record book showing all information relevant to the case of each person
passing through police custody, providing proof of the duration of each phase of custody
and of the authority responsible, and certification by the relevant authority of all transfer
of custody;
(b)
Jueces de ejecución should carry out their mandate proactively as set forth in
the criminal procedure code, and need to be equipped for the purpose (e.g. with vehicles
and information technology);
(c)
Measures need to be taken to render public defence more effective. These
could include both providing material resources, such as offices, computers, vehicles, and
providing training. However, on a more fundamental level, thought will need to be given
on how to strengthen their role as lawyers acting on behalf of a client, even if they are paid
out of public funds;
(d)
In all events, when the legal basis for deprivation of a person’s liberty has
expired, whether held in a police station, a prison, or an IHNFA facility, the authority
holding the detainee must release him or her, without any further need for a judicial
decision.
101. Honduras needs to establish a penitentiary system as a separate institution, run by
professional penitentiary management and staff, not connected to the police. Such a
separate system is necessary to prevent arbitrary detention and ensure that, as prescribed
by the Constitution, detention is aimed at rehabilitation and preparation for a working life
outside prison.
102. In the meantime, already before legislation to this effect can be passed and put into
practice, steps should be taken to bring the prison system closer to compliance with the
Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners. Penitentiary facilities should
respect the separation between remand and convict detainees; women should be held
separately from men; persons with serious mental health problems and those terminally ill
require special attention which is better provided outside prison. Internal disciplinary and
complaints procedures should be established and complied with, so that the rule of law
extends to penitentiary facilities.
103. All branches of Government, seeking input from civil society as well, should
reconsider the response of both the criminal justice system and the State in general to the
young men and women belonging to maras. The current system, based exclusively on
repression, in particular rules governing detention which in practice violate international
human rights law, does not appear to be able to either address the root of the problem or
enhance the security of the population.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents