PART B – Interview – ethical and clinical considerations
For all these and other similar perceptions,
the subject may experience distress, fear,
mistrust, forced submission, anger, rage,
shame, worry or suspicion, or he/she may
become too trusting and expectant.
(See § 265 and § 268 in the Istanbul Protocol.)
15
expert on trauma or the last hope of the
survivor
• Feelings of insecurity
• Feelings of guilt
• Excessive rage toward torturers and persecutors or toward the individual.
During the interview, all these factors may
lead the evaluator:
2. COUNTER-TRANSFERENCE
“[...]The clinician’s emotional response to the
torture survivor, known as countertransference, may affect the psychological evaluation” (Istanbul Protocol, § 265).
If a clinician is unaware of counter-transference, it may cause some additional problems, barriers during the interviews and also
may diminish the clinician’s effectivity and
ability to evaluate and document the consequences of torture.
Common counter-transference reactions include:
• Avoidance, withdrawal, defensive indifference
• Disillusionment, helplessness, hopelessness and over-identification
• Omnipotence and grandiosity in the
form of feeling like a saviour, the great
• to underestimate the severity of the consequences of torture
• to forget some details
• to have ungrounded doubts about the
truth of the alleged torture
• to fail to establish needed empathic approach
• to experience difficulty in maintaining
objectivity
• to experience over-identification with
the torture survivor
• not to be able to obtain the history
• not to be able to formulate the case and
to prepare the report on time and properly.
Torture can also lead to vicarious traumatisation, secondary traumatization and/or
burn-out reactions on the side of the interviewer.
(See §§ 148-149 and §§ 263-273 in the Istanbul Protocol
and Bustos, 1990; Herman, 1992; Smith et al., 1996;
Steele et al., 2001 )
VIII. FACTORS LEADING TO INCONSISTENCIES AND DIFFICULTIES IN RECALLING AND RECOUNTING THE STORY OF
TORTURE
Torture survivors may have difficulties in recalling and recounting the specific details of
the torture experience and other parts of the
history for several important reasons. There
might also be other factors which make it
difficult to obtain sufficient information
during an interview.
Impaired attention and memory disorders
are part of PTSD, but these symptoms may
also be present in other disorders such as
depression, anxiety, brain injury or electrolyte imbalance. Memory impairment might
also be a symptom of dissociation, which
often can be a protective coping strategy in
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents