levels to strictly control the production, promotion, trade, transfer3 and use of policing and other law
enforcement equipment. In 2005 Amnesty International and Omega were instrumental in the EU’s
adoption of regulations that ban the production and export of specific “tools of torture” and strictly
control trade in other equipment which, while intended for law enforcement, can easily be misused
for torture or other ill-treatment.4 Amnesty International and Omega continue to campaign for these
regulations to be strengthened in the EU and adopted globally.
Amnesty International and Omega are calling on the Chinese authorities to bring China’s national
regulation of law enforcement equipment into line with this emerging international framework. The
Chinese authorities should prohibit the production, use and export of “tools of torture”. China must
also reform its export licencing system for law enforcement equipment, making the system transparent and publicly accountable. Strict, human rights-based criteria must be applied and met before
export licences are issued. More broadly, there must be a greater understanding of the potential
problems associated with law enforcement equipment, and the rationale behind the regulation of its
design, transfer and use. Concrete steps need to be taken by all states, not only China, to combat
the misuse of legitimate law enforcement equipment by law enforcement agencies around the world.
Methodology
Amnesty International and the Omega Research Foundation have collaborated in the research and writing
of this report. The report draws upon the detailed field investigations and analysis of torture and other
cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment as well as unnecessary and excessive use of force in China and
other countries, undertaken by Amnesty International’s researchers around the world over the past five
years. It also draws upon research by Amnesty International on conditions in China’s recently abolished
Re-education Through Labour (RTL) detention system, which included interviews with over 60 detainees
conducted between May 2009 and November 2013, as well as the on-going monitoring of violations of the
rights of human rights defenders, ethnic minorities and religious groups in China.
The dataset of information about companies involved in the law enforcement equipment trade on which
this report draws has been maintained and updated by Omega, which has researched the global police
and security equipment market since 1990. Omega carries out market surveying on a continuous basis
and gathers current as well as historical market, product and trade data from a wide range of open and
commercial sources. These include company-produced information from websites and product brochures;
industry sector publications; government publications; company and financial information from national
company registries; government- and commercially-produced trade statistics; media organizations; and
credible reports and publications by NGOs and international governmental organizations (IGOs). Unless
otherwise stated, data about the size, scope and evolution of China’s manufacture of law enforcement
equipment is taken from Omega’s datasets.
The data in this report concerns Chinese entities manufacturing and trading law enforcement equipment
and is a subset of data held by Omega on the global trade in these products and services. Although this
report is principally concerned with state actors’ use of and trade in security equipment for law enforcement
and detention, many companies also supply equipment for use by private security providers. As China does
not publish information about the export of security and police equipment it is often difficult to ascertain
the level of these exports. For this reason, this report draws upon data from Chinese companies themselves,
Chinese shipments, media reports from various sources, and photographic evidence of Chinese equipment
being used outside China by foreign security personnel.
4
China’s Trade in Tools of Torture and Repression
Amnesty International – Index: ASA 17/042/2014