Report of the Commissioner for Human Rights on the activities of the National Mechanism for the Prevention of Torture in Poland in 2017
Why is solving the problem of overcrowding in cells so important?
Having served their sentences, prisoners will be released and the conditions in which they
were serving their sentences will have impact on their rehabilitation and future relations with
others57.
Such small space in a cell fails to ensure even a minimum level of privacy; it becomes the
source of frustration, mental suffering, conflicts and violence.
In such conditions it is hugely difficult for the Prison Service to ensure safety to prisoners.
Limited space hinders the performance of therapeutic activities and may strengthen or
deepen non-psychiatric mental disorders or mental retardation that some prisoners may
suffer from.
Small living space also involves a higher risk of infectious diseases (e.g. viral hepatitis, tuberculosis, scabies).
Moreover, placing individuals in such constrained spaces entails a risk of inhuman and
degrading treatment, which collides with the international obligations of Poland.
Such treatment of prisoners is an affront to a modern European country and significantly
deviates from international standards.
Both CPT as well as CAT have been calling on Polish authorities to introduce changes in
that regard.
Failure to introduce them entails the risk of passing unfavourable rulings against Poland by
the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg.
In such a situation, also the risk of paying compensation adjudicated to prisoners by Polish
courts is on the rise.
European courts examining the request of a Polish court to apply the European Arrest
Warrant (EAW) will be able to postpone the execution of the warrant, if they assume that
there is a risk of degrading treatment of a prisoner in Poland due to insufficient living space
in a cell.
57
(2017) 5, Article 56
See also the CHR’s General Intervention of 24.05.2016 and 29.07.2016 to the Minister of Justice, KMP.571.5.2016.RK
27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents