Recently, interest has focused on economic and social indicators, probably
because it has been recognised that the content of ESC rights needs better
definition. But indicators can certainly be used to monitor civil and political rights.
It may be possible to record or estimate the number of people detained without
charge, for example. Has the government made money available to fund legal
aid? Have police officers been trained to apply international standards related
to arrest and detention? Most of these indicators can also be disaggregated.
Ways of disaggregating indicators: the right to health
The right to health imposes obligations on government to ensure provision
of various services, including universal primary health care, other preventive
and curative medical services, and affordable essential drugs of good
quality. But the right to health goes far beyond medical services. The key
determinants of health are levels of economic well-being leading to good
housing, sanitation and nutrition. This has important implications for
governments as well as other actors, including pharmaceutical companies
and health professionals.
Since the right to health can be disaggregated, indicators can be devised
for each of its elements. A general indicator can be broken down to shed
light on the access to health of particular groups: children, the elderly or
women; or on the allocation of investments: in medical services, housing
or sanitation; or on the availability of drugs. Indicators can equally track
what proportions of the health budget are spent on drugs, personnel,
building hospitals, immunisation, urban versus rural areas, etc. All these
figures can be analysed over time to show trends and priorities and make
comparison between heads of expenditure. Taken further, such indicators
can be compared with statistical information on infant mortality rate and life
expectancy – for example, in rural areas, to help set policy priorities and
analyse given changes in public health policies.
Other indicators can be developed to make comparisons across sectors.
Health spending can be calculated as a proportion of the government
budget and gross domestic product, and compared with other areas of
spending such as education, the judiciary or defence. Such indicators can
help to show whether progress is being made towards realising the right
to health, or if the sector is slipping backwards. Along with other forms of
budget analysis, they can be a helpful guide to the government’s priorities,
year by year, and over time.
B. Using indicators to evaluate NHRIs’ performance
Indicators are most effectively used to measure the performance of an institution
when they are fully integrated within the NHRI’s planning, implementation and
evaluation processes.
When evaluation criteria are established (at least broadly) at the planning
stage, the institution’s aims and associated indicators can function as targets
32 Assessing the Effectiveness of National Human Rights Institutions
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents