CHARACTERISTICS OF FEMALE PRISONERS
CONTEXT: Reasons for imprisonment
Whilst the crimes committed by both men
and women are often closely interrelated
to their personal histories and economic
situations, it should be recognised that
there are many women and girls who are
imprisoned after being pressured or duped
into participating in criminal activities, or
who have been imprisoned due to their
association with others engaged in illegal
behaviour. In some cases, women are
imprisoned for crimes committed in response
to coercion by abusive partners.
A 2007 study demonstrated that the
situation of women prisoners in Afghanistan
posed a particular dilemma in relation to
rehabilitation efforts.27 The report found
that many of the women imprisoned were
innocent but had been convicted because
they had no legal assistance or because
they had been forced to confess. Others had
been used or framed by male relatives or
were arrested because they were with their
husbands or partners when the crime was
committed. As a result, offending behaviour
programmes – aimed at addressing the
underlying causes leading to crime – were
not relevant because the women were
victims themselves and therefore had entirely
different needs.
A 2019 study of 10 women from Thailand
imprisoned in Cambodia for cross-border
drug trafficking revealed life histories
marred by a range of vulnerabilities,
including individual (for example, mental ill
health), relational (such as parental abuse
and domestic violence), and social (for
example, low levels of education and limited
employment opportunities). All of the women
had carried drugs across international
borders for somebody else. None were
career criminals nor had knowledge of the
international drug trade. Their offending
was characterised by a lack of control and
involved varying degrees of exploitation.28
12 |
In a 2012 study of female offenders in South
Africa, 55 per cent of the women interviewed
said they had become involved in criminal
activity because they needed to provide
for their families. Others reported that they
turned to crime in an effort to emancipate
themselves from abusive partners, spouses
or parents.29
In Kyrgyzstan, one report noted that
70 per cent of women convicted of killing
their husband or other family member
had experienced a ‘longstanding pattern
of physical abuse or forced economic
dependence’.30 Another study in Kyrgyzstan
found that of 27 women convicted of murder
or manslaughter of a male family member,
three said they had acted to protect children,
10 had experienced sexual abuse, 14 had
experienced frequent domestic abuse, and
15 said that it was an act of self-defence.31
One study illustrated how black women
in the US had been forced to commit
offences due to physical attacks or even
death threats, or following more subtle
pressure or provocation. This included being
manipulated or ‘talked into’ committing the
offence, confessing to an abuser’s crime, or
committing physical assaults in response
to psychological victimisation.32 In Mexico,
it has been estimated that at least 40 per
cent of women convicted of drug-related
crimes, such as transporting drugs between
cities or smuggling drugs into prisons, were
coerced into doing so by their boyfriends
or husbands.33
Research on 13 women prisoners at Idrizovo
prison in the Republic of Macedonia
found that virtually all of the women had
experienced serious violence at the hands
of their husbands or partners, with most
of the women reporting that they felt safer
inside prison than outside. The research
also found that most of the crimes the
women committed were related to their
previous abuse.34
Penal Reform International and Thailand Institute of Justice | Guide to the rehabilitation and social reintegration of women prisoners
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents