Foreword by the Chairman
Foreword by the Chairman
The Federal Act on the Commission for the Prevention of Torture gives the Commission a mandate to, among other things,
inspect detention facilities and submit recommendations to the
responsible authorities “with the objective of improving the treatment and living conditions of persons who have been deprived of
their liberty”.
This mission appears unobjectionable at first glance. However,
it has proved to be a major challenge in practice. The reports prepared by the NCPT following its inspections include, as the law
requires, observations concerning the need for improvements at
the facilities in question and recommendations on how this can
be achieved. Inevitably, these observations contain an element of
criticism, otherwise there would be no need for recommendations. These assessments can sometimes spark some irritation and
annoyance. The Commission does not always succeed in formulating the recommendations in such a way as to make them understood not as negative judgments, but as well-intended encouragement to review possibilities for improvement.
Often, we are accused of having focused only on the negative
rather than accentuating the positive. I can understand these ob-
Activity Report NCPT 2017
1