E/CN.4/2006/6/Add.3
page 11
institutions without prior permission. In addition, the Chairperson of the Human Rights and
Civil Integration Committee of Parliament has informed the Special Rapporteur that she
undertakes regular visits to places of detention. The Special Rapporteur also notes information
that joint visits by the National Security Council, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the
General Procurator’s Office and the Public Defender are envisaged. While these mechanisms
may contribute to a degree of prevention of torture and ill-treatment, as they currently function
they demonstrate a number of shortcomings, primarily widely differing mandates; lack of overall
coordination among them; lack of a regular and systematic programme of visits, including
regular follow-up; lack of investigatory powers; lack of adequate resources; and lack of
independence, particularly in the case of the council appointed by the President.
III. CONDITIONS IN DETENTION
40.
The Special Rapporteur isolated the practice of torture and ill-treatment in Georgia from
the generally deplorable conditions of detention he found.
A. Facilities of the Ministry of Internal Affairs
41.
Following arrest suspects in police stations are then transferred to temporary isolators for
a period of up to 72 hours.
42.
On 22 February 2005, he visited the Vake-Saburtalo District Police Station, Arakisvili
Street, Tbilisi, and the Vake-Saburtalo Police Station No. 2, Vaza Pshvala Street. At the District
Police Station, the Special Rapporteur met with the duty officer, Mr. G. Rogava. He noted that
the register of detainees was well kept, and that while there was a central register of cases for the
district, there was no similar register of arrests. There were two empty cells, of approximately
1.5 x 2 m, each with a wooden bench, but without lighting or toilet facilities. According to the
registers most persons were detained for two to three hours prior to transfer to the temporary
isolator of the Tbilisi Head Department of Internal Affairs. At Vake-Saburtalo Police Station
No. 2, the Special Rapporteur met with the station chief, Mr. A. Eloshvili. The facility was
undergoing renovation at the time. One of the detainees interviewed said that he was well
treated, informed of his right to a lawyer, was able to inform his family and, despite the
renovations, was in relative comfort.
43.
On 24 February 2005, the Special Rapporteur visited the temporary isolator of the Tbilisi
Head Department of Internal Affairs, where he met with the duty officer, Mr. K. Khakhishvili,
and the deputy chief of the isolator, Mr. F. Chankvetadze. Although many of the allegations of
ill-treatment received by the Special Rapporteur specified that it took place in cells in the upper
floors of the building, the staff indicated that there were no such cells, only offices. Eight
interrogation and 14 detention cells were examined. The cells were very cold, damp, dark
and filthy. Only four of the detention cells had beds, whereas the others had only raised
wood-panelled floors for detainees to sleep on. Blankets were the only bedding provided. Each
cell had a latrine separated by a waist-high partition. No toilet paper or washing facilities were
available in the cells. There were no allegations of ill-treatment by the detainees interviewed.
However, the conditions of detention were very poor.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents