categories of prisoners
should be implemented.
(w)
inmate status and release entitlement,
increased crime rates, high recidivism
rates, and the popularity of tougher law and
order approaches favouring longer prison
terms over alternative sentences - has
resulted in severely overcrowded prisons
(A/HRC/11/2/Add.2, para. 42).
Non-governmental sources: At present the
prison population is around 460,000,
leaving a shortfall of 160,000 places in the
system. Even though the federal
government has invested in building new
prisons, no building programme can match
the rate of growth of the number of
detainees. As such, any semblance of
separation or categorization of prisoners is
not done, to the extent that juveniles and
women can be detained with adult males.
Permanent monitoring
must be present in every
institution and in places of
detention for juveniles. (x)
Non-governmental sources: Concern has
been expressed about the interference with
human rights groups or officially
authorised prison visiting bodies, such as
the community council of Rio de Janeiro,
or conselho da comunidade, a prison
inspection body made up of the authorities
and civil society. The authorities reportedly
placed pressure on the judge of the penal
executions court, or juiz da vara de
execuções penais, to replace the president
of the conselho da comunidade, who was
widely critical of the state’s prison system.
Non-governmental sources: Oversight has
been further hindered by political and
judicial intervention against those few
bodies that are both mandated to monitor
prisons and had previously been working
A/HRC/13/39/Add.6
23
In São Paulo, human rights groups were
blocked from visiting the FEBEM juvenile
detention system, visited by the Special
Rapporteur in 2000, where it is reported
that torture and ill-treatment remains
widespread and systematic. Although the
state authorities of São Paulo have granted
There are many bodies with the legal
authority to investigate prison conditions,
but they have not provided adequate
oversight in practice. This lack of external
oversight has permitted poor prison
conditions and abuses of power to
continue. The law provides for a number of
organs to inspect and monitor prisons.
However, inmates interviewed had rarely
seen or even heard of a visit by an external
prison monitor. They were aware of rare
visits by prison internal affairs, but no
visits by a judge, prison council, or other
prison oversight body (A/HRC/11/2/Add.2,
paras. 47-48).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents