the Catholic Prison Ministry,
community councils and state
human rights councils. In many
places, the latter two do not exist
or do not function; some lack the
necessary resources (mainly
some ouvidorias); and others
lack the genuine independence
necessary to do effective work
(some corregedorias).
councils on human rights continue to vary
dramatically around the country. In those
few cases where these councils have been
working effectively, there are extremely
worrying reports of politically motivated
attempts to hinder or undermine their
work. For example, in Rio de Janeiro, state
government with judicial collaboration,
managed to oust the president of the
community council after he made persistent
denunciations of violations. In the state of
Espírito Santo, where the prison system is
riddled with corruption and human rights
violations, the state authorities have
managed to bar all access to prisons by the
officially mandated human rights council
and all other human rights or religious
groups.
The police should be
unified under civilian
authority and justice.
Congress should approve
the draft law to transfer the
ordinary courts jurisdiction
over manslaughter, causing
bodily harm and other
crimes including torture
committed by the military
police. (s)
The split police system makes
external monitoring of the
military police very difficult.
Non-governmental sources: There is no
recent information of attempts to introduce
structural reform of the police or legal
reform allowing for the prosecution of
police in civil courts.
Police stations should be
transformed into
institutions offering a
public service. (t)
External investigation is overly
dependent on the goodwill and
cooperation of the heads of
police stations that hold
exorbitant power.
Non-governmental sources: While some
efforts were made, most notably in Rio de
Janeiro, to change the structure and nature
of police stations, there is no current
information to suggest that such
fundamental reforms have been effectively
realized.
A qualified medical
Detainees must request a
The state institutes of forensic medicine in
21
A/HRC/13/39/Add.6
provided for community
and state councils on
human rights and police
and prison ombudsmen.
Fully-resourced community
councils with unrestricted
access to all places of
detention should be
established in each state. (r)
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents