A/HRC/28/68
do not have prompt and private access to legal assistance or notification of their parents or
caregivers, which makes them even more vulnerable and subject to a higher risk of being
subjected to torture or other ill-treatment.
41.
Despite the international legal framework in place, the majority of children deprived
of their liberty are held in pretrial detention, often for prolonged periods, and for minor
offences, often in unsuitable premises. 10 In many countries, the excessive use of pretrial
detention leads to overcrowded facilities.
42.
Many States continue to hold children and adults in the same facilities, in particular
those in pretrial detention and police custody, but also during transportation or in the
context of immigration detention. Moreover, the continuous trying and sentencing of
children as adults and the lack of specialized juvenile facilities have resulted in numerous
children being placed in adult prisons. Disciplinary and other administrative rules and
procedures are often applied, regardless of child status.
43.
Detaining children and adults together will inevitably result in negative
consequences for the children, who are five times as likely to be subjected to a
substantiated incident of sexual violence, and are also much more likely to witness or
experience other forms of violence, including physical harm by facility staff members. 11
They are also more likely to commit suicide or engage in other forms of self-harm when
housed in adult – rather than juvenile – facilities. Research also shows that imprisoning
children with adults can result in increased recidivism and negative long-term consequences
for children, their families and communities. 12
44.
In many States, solitary confinement is still imposed on children as a disciplinary or
“protective” measure. National legislation often contains provisions to permit children to be
placed in solitary confinement. The permitted time frame and practices vary between days,
weeks and even months. In accordance with views of the Committee against Torture, the
Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture and the Committee on the Rights of the Child, the
Special Rapporteur is of the view that the imposition of solitary confinement, of any
duration, on children constitutes cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment or
even torture (see A/66/268, paras. 77 and 86, and A/68/295, para. 61). 13
45.
During country visits, the Special Rapporteur regularly observes the practice of
corporal punishment as a disciplinary measure for children in detention, including severe
caning, flogging, beating with sticks and electric cords, beatings on the buttocks with
wooden boards, and being forced to kneel for long periods with hands in the air
(A/HRC/25/60/Add.1, paras. 64-65 and A/HRC/22/53/Add.2, para. 56). Some States still
allow the use of corporal punishment as a criminal sentence for children. With regard to the
jurisprudence of United Nations treaty bodies and the European Court, the mandate holder
has found that any form of corporal punishment is contrary to the prohibition of torture and
other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment (see A/60/316 and A/67/279).
10
11
12
13
Ibid. and A/HRC/21/25, para. 8.
See Anna Volz, “Stop the Violence! The overuse of pre-trial detention, or the need to reform juvenile
justice systems”, Defence for Children International, Geneva, July 2010, p. 16.
Information received from the American Civil Liberties Union during the expert consultation held in
Washington, D.C. on 10 and 11 November 2014.
See also A/HRC/22/53/Add.1, para. 73; United Nations Rules for the Protection of
Juveniles Deprived of their Liberty, para. 67; Committee on the Rights of the Child,
general comment No. 10 (CRC/C/GC/10), para. 89.
9