-35
is deprived of liberty, any recourse to physical force which has not been
made strictly necessary by his own conduct diminishes human dignity
and is an infringement of Article 3 ECHR.52
As soon as force is used against a prisoner for one of the purposes indicated
under Art 1 of the United Nations Convention against Torture (CAT), i.e.
extracting a confession, intimidation, punishment and discrimination,
any infliction of severe pain or suffering is to be qualified as torture,
which means that it will be absolutely prohibited under any circumstances
and no proportionality test will be allowed.53
3.2.2. Ensuring accountability and protecting victims of violence
Establishing an effective complaint mechanism as well as investigating
and prosecuting instances of violence are crucial steps to ensure
accountability according to international standards and to foster a climate
of trust in prison (see in this series the Handbook on Complaints).54 Equally
important to this end are the establishment of appropriate procedures,
such as the systematic recording and documentation of injuries, closed
circuit television (CCTV) monitoring as well as guaranteeing victims’
rights and protection against reprisals.
Medical personnel plays a central role in this regard. They can contribute to
the prevention of violence against detained persons and more specifically of
torture and ill-treatment, through the systematic recording and documentation
of injuries.55 Access to medical examinations by a qualified health-care
professional should be granted as soon as possible after a person is admitted
to a place of detention or whenever they were involved in a violent incident.56
52. ECtHR, Tali v Estonia, No 66393/10, 13 February 2014, § 59; ECtHR, Artyomov v Russia, No 14146/02,
27 May 2010, § 145; ECtHR, Bouyid v Belgium, No 23380/09, 28 September 2015, § 101; see also ECtHR,
Guide: Prisoners’ Rights.
53. Nowak/Birk/Monina 58ff.
54. Detailed guidance on the modalities of such investigations can be found in the following documents:
Manual on the Effective Investigation and Documentation of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading
Treatment or Punishment: Istanbul Protocol (United Nations Publication 2004) HR/P/PT/8/Rev.1. See also
the CoE, Effective Investigation of Ill-Treatment: Guidelines on European Standards (CoE 2014).
55. UNGA, ‘Body of Principles for the Protection of All Persons under Any Form of Detention or
Imprisonment’, Res 43/173 of 9 December 1988 (Body of Principles) Principle 24; EPR Rules 16 and 42;
and Mandela Rules, Rules 34 and 46. See also CoE, CM, ‘Recommendation No R(98) 7 of the committee of
Ministers to Member States Concerning the Ethical and Organisational Aspects of Health Care in Prison’
(1998) R(98)7; and by the CPT standards regarding health care services in prisons, particularly CPT, ‘3rd
General Report on the CPT’s Activities, 1 January-31 December 1992’ (1993) CPT/Inf (93) 12, 13ff. For
more details see also Dignity 2020, and PRI and others, Guidance Document, 157ff.
56. See EPR Rule 42.3(c);Mandela Rules; CPT, ‘Developments Concerning CPT Standards in Respect
Monitoring Prison Violence
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents