-39
Large capacity dormitories – units containing all or most of the facilities
used by prisoners on a daily basis, such as sleeping and living areas as well as
sanitary facilities – are also often identified as factors conducive to violence.
STANDARDS IN FOCUS
According to CPT, ‘Large-capacity dormitories inevitably imply
a lack of privacy for prisoners in their everyday lives. Moreover,
the risk of intimidation and violence is high. Such accommodation
arrangements are prone to foster the development of offender
subcultures, and facilitate the maintenance of the cohesion of criminal
organisations. They can also render proper staff control extremely
difficult, if not impossible; more specifically, in case of prison
disturbances, outside interventions involving the use of considerable
force are difficult to avoid. With such accommodation, the appropriate
allocation of individual prisoners, based on a case by case risk and
needs assessment, also becomes an almost impossible exercise.’66
The CPT has thus consistently recommended moving away from this
type of accommodation towards smaller units to be accompanied by
measures to ensure that prisoners spend a reasonable part of their
day engaged in purposeful activities outside their living units.
The EPR go beyond this and explicitly state that ‘prisoners shall
normally be accommodated during the night in individual cells’, and
an exception to this rule may only be required if this is in the own
interest of the prisoners.67 Existing prison architecture along with
other factors may make it difficult to accommodate prisoners in
single cells. However, the requirement of accommodation in single
cells should be taken into account for new prisons.
3.2.3.2. Prison regime and purposeful activities
The activities and opportunities offered to prisoners are as important in
preventing violence as security and safety measures or material conditions.
66. CPT/Inf(2001)16-part, § 29.
67. EPR, Rule 18.5; see also Mandela Rules, Rule 12; European Committee on Crime Problems (CDPC),
Council for Penological Co-Operation (PC-CP), Revised Commentary to Recommendation CM/
Rec(2006)2 of the Committee of Ministers to member States on the European Prison Rules (2018) PC-CP
(2018) 1 rev 2, 12-13.
Monitoring Prison Violence
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents