Annual Report 2012: Spain’s National Preventive Mechanism
istries, associations and groups that were affected to enable them to give their
opinion regarding the draft.
There are numerous legal
gaps in the forced
committal of elderly
persons to residential care
centers
The non-voluntary
committal of elderly
persons to residential care
centers must also be
regulated
Maximum specialization of
judicial bodies should be
achieved
The creation of a Public
Prosecutor’s Office
specialized in the
protection of persons with
disabilities is recommended
132
168. In respect to forced committal to residential care centers for the elderly
and the disabled, Law 39/2006, of 14 December, on the Promotion of Personal
Autonomy and Care of persons in a situation of dependency includes, in the
rights of persons in a situation of dependency, the right «to freely decide regard
ing entering a living residence, and to the full exercise of their jurisdictional
rights in the case of involuntary committal, with the guarantee of contradictory
proceedings». Notwithstanding the foregoing, the important legal gaps that ex
ist in this respect have given rise to the application by public administrations as
well as judges and public prosecutors of criteria that is contradictory and has
very different implications. Given the disparity of figures regarding proceedings
initiated in the different regional autonomous communities shown in Table 172,
the difference of criteria that exists in each judicial district in respect to the re
quirement of having or not judicial authorization for committing persons to
certain centers can be inferred.
In consequence, the NPM has asked the Office of the Secretary of State that the
aforementioned organic draft bill also regulate the non-voluntary committal of
elderly persons to residential care centers when they are not in condition to pro
vide valid consent, establishing necessary legal guarantees for the full respect of
the rights of citizens, both fundamental rights and specific rights in the field of
health.
169. In order to guarantee the respect and protection of the rights of persons for
whom forced committal or a declaration of incapacity is requested, the NPM has
informed the General Council of the Spanish Judicial Authority (abbreviated as
CGPJ in Spanish) that judicial bodies must acquire maximum specialization and
that matters of forced committal and incapacitation in major cities should cor
respond to a single judge, where this has not yet occurred and where there are
several judges. In this respect, the General Council of the Spanish Judicial Au
thority has pointed out that when specialization is not possible in a judicial dis
trict due to the workload, incapacity, committal and guardianship proceedings
are sent to a sole court, making it easier to adopt uniform criteria and speeding
up the resolution of conflicts.
Likewise, information has been requested from the Spanish Attorney General’s
Office (abbreviated as FGE in Spanish) regarding the current level of specializa
tion in the Provincial Public Prosecutor’s Office in respect to the protection of
persons with disabilities, and regarding the existence in different Public Prosecu
tor Offices of guidelines for public prosecutors in charge of the protection of per
sons with disabilities to regularly inspect centers, residential care centers and
supervised apartments, pursuant to the faculty-duty assigned to the Public Pros
ecutor’s Office in Article 4.2 of its Organic Statute. In any case, the creation of a
Public Prosecutor’s Office specialized in the protection of persons with disabiliTHE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents