E/CN.4/1997/7/Add.2
page 13
could not be overheard. Despite this modicum of privacy, many detainees
expressed concerns that they would suffer reprisals following the departure of
the Special Rapporteur, and therefore, some, but not all, mainly in Karachi,
refused to provide any testimony about possible abuses on the part of the
police, Rangers or prison staff. The Special Rapporteur notes with concern
that upon his return from Pakistan he received a letter signed by inmates of
Karachi Central Jail who claimed that they had been denied permission to meet
with the Special Rapporteur and that they had been moved prior to his visit
because they could provide testimony of the torture that is inflicted upon
the prisoners by the staff of the jail.
46.
Most of the prisoners who dared to speak claimed to have been ill treated
while in custody and/or to have witnessed the ill-treatment of other
prisoners. The ill-treatment described included beatings, burning with
cigarettes, whippings with rubber or leather straps, sexual assault, being
hung upside down for prolonged periods, electric shocks, deprivation of sleep,
mock executions, the use of fetters, blindfolding for periods of up to 16 days
and public humiliation. Although many of these prisoners claimed that the
police, Rangers and prison officials had used force to elicit confessions and
to compel detainees to incriminate others, some indicated that the force was
used to extort money or merely to humiliate individuals. Marks of torture
were visible on several of the prisoners; one prisoner removed his shirt to
show the Special Rapporteur the large welts on his back caused by whippings
with a leather strap.
47.
In the testimony describing his detention from 30 November
to 4 December 1995 at CIA headquarters in Hyderabad (see paras. 28 and 29
above), Dr. Halepota testified that he was held in what the officials called
the "torture cell" and interrogated by a joint interrogation team of CIA and
military intelligence. Although he himself was not ill treated physically, he
claimed to have witnessed the torture of 11 inmates. The other inmates were
allegedly subjected to blindfolding, beatings with fists and implements,
incisions on their skin with blades, whippings with wooden strips, being hung
upside down and deprivation of food and water.
48.
With regard to the custody of women, a 1994 amendment to the Criminal
Procedure Code prohibits a magistrate from authorizing the detention in police
custody of a female except in cases involving qatl (murder) or dacoity. This
amendment also requires the police officer undertaking investigation of a
female to interrogate the accused in the prison in the presence of an officer
of the jail and a female police officer. Despite these safeguards, the
Special Rapporteur received numerous allegations of women being held in police
custody and raped. The Special Rapporteur regrets that he was unable to
investigate these allegations during the mission, but he took note of several
cases reported by the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan in which policemen
were charged with rape.
49.
During the mission, the Special Rapporteur also received reliable reports
that medical care is frequently denied to detainees who have been seriously
injured or are seriously ill. One case presented to the Special Rapporteur
concerned a young man, Ghulam Hyder, who had been shot by the police during
the course of his arrest. The gunshot wound had left him paralysed and his
health had further deteriorated while in custody at Karachi Central Jail.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents