E/CN.4/1997/7/Add.2
page 8
requested the Special Rapporteur to come to FIA headquarters to receive
authorization to enter the premises. The Special Rapporteur reiterated
his view that the authorization could be conveyed by telephone.
25.
While the Special Rapporteur waited for the authorization, a member
of the delegation spoke with private citizens close by the house. These
individuals informed the member of the delegation that the detainees were held
only in the basement. They also indicated that approximately 16 individuals
were currently being held there and that there were armed guards on the roof
of the house and inside, in addition to the two armed guards stationed outside
the front door. A member of the delegation counted some eight policemen in
the yard between the door and the gate during the period the delegation was
there.
26.
After one and a half hours a bus and two four-wheel vehicles arrived at
the house. The Special Rapporteur could only assume that these vehicles had
been sent to transport prisoners detained inside the house. After two hours
the Special Rapporteur decided that it was futile to remain any longer as it
had become clear that authorization to enter the house was being denied at the
highest level of the Ministry of the Interior.
27.
The Special Rapporteur immediately met with the Secretary of the Ministry
of Human Rights and senior officials of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to
protest at the denial of access to the house, which he considered to be a
clear violation of the terms of reference of the mission. These officials
indicated that the Special Rapporteur was free to return to the house and
inspect the premises. This offer was reiterated in a later telephone
conversation with Senator Iqbal Haider. The Special Rapporteur considered
that to return to the house would serve no useful purpose.
28.
The Special Rapporteur subsequently received further information
indicating that FIA operates incommunicado detention centres or "safe houses"
in Islamabad. Dr. Munawar A. Halepota, Secretary-General of the World Sindhi
Congress and Human Rights International, provided testimony to the Special
Rapporteur that he was arrested without charge on 28 November 1995 and
initially held in the Tando Allahyar police station for two days. He was
then transferred on 30 November to the Central Investigation Agency Centre
in Hyderabad. On 4 December he was handed over to FIA and transferred to
Islamabad for further interrogation. From 4 to 18 December, Dr. Halepota was
held in FIA custody at a "safe house" between Islamabad and Faizabad. Based
upon the description provided by Dr. Halepota, the Special Rapporteur believes
this facility to be the one to which he was denied access during his mission.
Dr. Halepota was subsequently deported from Pakistan to the United Kingdom.
29.
The treatment received by Dr. Halepota was the same as that received by
the individual who provided testimony to the Special Rapporteur on the FIA
"safe house". In both cases, the detainees were kept in a dark, cold, damp
room in the basement, which, Dr. Halepota testified, is referred to as the
"refrigerator". Both were made to sleep on a concrete floor. Dr. Halepota
informed the Special Rapporteur that during his detention many Egyptians were
held in the "safe house" in connection with the embassy bombing that occurred
in 1995. He claims that they were taken regularly to be tortured.