CAT/OP/CRI/ROSP/1
to reduce overcrowding in prisons and would like to be informed of the specific
measures taken and of progress made in this area.
Food and physical conditions in prisons
52.
Physical conditions varied, depending on how long ago the detention facilities had
been built. Many prisons had old facilities and, in some cases, clogged toilets. Elsewhere,
such as the C cell block of the Nelson Mandela closed rehabilitation centre, former
storerooms had been converted into dormitories. The physical conditions in less restrictive
environments, such as the “cottages” of the Nelson Mandela closed rehabilitation centre,
were generally better, although there were signs of incipient overcrowding. The
Subcommittee was informed of problems with storm drains, which overflow when it rains
and flood the central courtyards of many cell blocks. The Subcommittee noted the presence
of insects in the dormitories and many of the foam mattresses were in an appalling state. The
Subcommittee was alarmed at the deplorable state of the wiring in almost all the detention
centres visited. Most of the wires were bare, posing a constant danger to detainees. In some
areas of the Marcos Garvey closed rehabilitation centre, many persons deprived of their
liberty reported water outages, which they claimed were sometimes imposed as a punishment.
53.
The Subcommittee recommends that the State party urgently take measures to
improve the physical conditions in Costa Rican prisons and that it develop a strategy
and an action plan to resolve the aforementioned problems. In particular, the
Subcommittee recommends that, in accordance with the United Nations Standard
Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules), prisoners
should have access to water, sufficient light and ventilation and working sanitary
facilities and should be provided with mattresses in good condition.
54.
During its visits of various prisons, the Subcommittee received complaints of
insufficient quantities of food, insufficiently cooked food, especially noodles, rice and beans,
and poor hygiene both in cooking and transporting food. In La Reforma, the Subcommittee
found that food was transported in open containers, allowing flies to land on it. In addition,
the cold-storage room had been out of order for two years, resulting in a disruption of the
cold chain. The Subcommittee found bagged meat that had already thawed but that had yet
to spend long hours at room temperature before being cooked the next day, thus posing health
risks. At the Nelson Mandela closed rehabilitation centre, the Subcommittee found oily
residue on serving dishes after they had been washed with cold water.
55.
The Subcommittee recommends that the relevant authorities take the necessary
measures to improve hygiene in cooking and transporting food, in order to prevent the
transmission of gastrointestinal infections within prisons. In particular, the authorities
should train the prison personnel and persons deprived of their liberty who work in
prison kitchens, as well as those responsible for transporting food, in hygienic and
responsible food management.
56.
According to information submitted by the State party, eight persons are responsible
for the nutrition of all persons deprived of their liberty in Costa Rica; four of these are
nutritionists and the other four are technicians specializing in nutrition. Two of the
nutritionists work in prisons and the other two work in central offices. The State party also
submitted information on nutritional planning and weekly menus. The Subcommittee did not
meet any nutritionists in the prisons it visited and it repeatedly heard allegations by persons
deprived of their liberty that meals were lacking in variety and nutritional value.
57.
The Subcommittee recommends increasing the number of nutritionists working
for the prison system so that they can develop and regularly update a balanced, varied
diet for prisoners that meets their nutritional needs.
58.
At the Marcos Garvey closed rehabilitation centre, the Subcommittee discovered that
microwaves may not be installed in the cell blocks because of electric wiring problems.
Persons deprived of their liberty claimed that, if they wished to warm up their food, they had
to pay 250 colones per dish to a mandadero. The Subcommittee visited the place where food
is heated up and was able to corroborate the existence of such an arrangement; the visiting
delegation was shown a receipt signed by management for the sum of 57,000 colones,
collected the previous day. The director of the place stated that the collection of such monies
10
GE.21-00153