A/HRC/7/3/Add.7
page 20
59. Whereas Law 27/2004 provides the legal basis for the establishment of the Indonesian
Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the Government has not created the commission so far,
although its statute provides that it must be formed within six months of the enactment of the
law. On 7 December 2006, the Constitutional Court ruled that Law No 27/2004 regarding the
Truth and Reconciliation Commission does not have a sound legal foundation and is inconsistent
with the Constitution,17 which delayed the establishment of a Truth and Reconciliation
Commission in Aceh,18 which has yet to be established.
B. Lack of prevention
Safeguards
Issue
Length of police custody
•
•
Right to legal assistance20
from moment of
arrest/detention at all stages
of examination;21 right to
speak at any time for the
defence of his case22
•
•
Situation observed
Maximum period of police
custody of 61 days19 is
applied as a standard
routine
Cells are not adapted for
prolonged custody;
detention may amount to
inhuman and degrading
treatment
Only few detainees had
legal assistance
Numerous complaints
regarding bias of legal aid
counsels
Recommendations
• Reduce the length of
police custody to
maximum 48 hours in
accordance with
international standards
• Prompt access to lawyers
can be a very effective
safeguard against
ill-treatment; Special
Rapporteur recommends
establishment of effective
and independent legal
assistance network
17
Constitutional Court decision No. 006/PUU-IV/2006, Thursday, 7 December 2006. The KKR
(the Truth and Reconciliation Commission) Law conflicts with Constitution 1945, see
http://www.mahkamahkonstitusi.go.id/berita.php?newscode=248.
18
It should have been created pursuant to point 2.3 of the Helsinki Memorandum of
Understanding.
19
KUHAP, arts. 16-31.
20
KUHAP, art. 69.
21
KUHAP, art. 69.
22
KUHAP, art. 70 (1).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents