20 years of combating torture: CPT General Report 2008-2009
Deprivation of liberty of irregular
migrants
77. In the course of its visits, the CPT has noted that a number of member States of the
Council of Europe have made a concerted effort to improve the conditions of detention
for irregular migrants. However, there are still far too many instances where the CPT
comes across places of deprivation of liberty for irregular migrants, and on occasion
asylum seekers, which are totally unsuitable. An illustrative example of such a place
would be a disused warehouse, with limited or no sanitation, crammed with beds or
mattresses on the floor, accommodating upwards of a hundred persons locked in
together for weeks or even months, with no activities, no access to outdoor exercise and
poor hygiene. CPT delegations also continue to find irregular migrants held in police
stations, in conditions that are barely acceptable for twenty-four hours, let alone weeks.
In some States, irregular migrants are detained in prisons. In the CPT’s opinion, a
prison establishment is by definition not a suitable place in which to hold someone who
is neither accused nor convicted of a criminal offence. Interestingly, prison managers and
staff in the various establishments visited by the CPT often agree that they are not
appropriately equipped or trained to look after irregular migrants. In this context, the
CPT wishes to reiterate that staff working in centres for irregular migrants have a
particularly onerous task. Consequently, they should be carefully selected and receive
appropriate training.
78. Despite the existence of many detention facilities for irregular migrants in Council
of Europe member States, there is still no comprehensive instrument covering the whole
of the European continent6 and setting out the minimum standards and safeguards for
irregular migrants deprived of their liberty, in line with the specific needs of this
particular group of persons.
The 2006 European Prison Rules apply to those irregular migrants who are
detained in prisons. However, it is stressed in the Commentary to the Rules that
immigration detainees should in principle not be held in prison. Therefore, the Rules do
not address the special needs and status of irregular migrants, such as those issues related
to the preparation and execution of deportation procedures. It should be noted here that
in accordance with Article 5 (1) f of the European Convention on Human Rights, irregular
migrants may be deprived of their liberty either when action is being taken with a view to
deportation or in order to prevent an unauthorised entry into the country. The purpose
of deprivation of liberty of irregular migrants is thus significantly different from that of
persons held in prison either on remand or as convicted offenders.
6.
Directive 2008/115/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of the European Union of 16 December 2008
on common standards and procedures in Member States for returning illegally staying third-country nationals
provides, inter alia, standards related to irregular migrants deprived of their liberty. The Directive is applicable in
most EU member States and some other countries and should be transposed into national legislation by the end of
2010.
38
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents