Table 1. Distribution of cases by content
Number and proportion of cases opened
Type of case
Cases accepted
for
proceedings,
including
constitutional
review
proceedings
ombudsman
proceedings
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
480
24.7%
449
22.1%
480
24%
395
22.7%
296
18.4%
411
26.5%
452
31%
151
7.8%
124
6.1%
168
8.4%
127
7.3%
98
6%
136
8.8%
151
10.3%
258
13.3%
231
11.4%
214
10.7%
186
10.6%
109
6.8%
168
10.8%
194
13.2%
special
proceedings
Nonsubstantive
proceedings of
cases
Total cases,
including
71
3.7%
94
4.6%
98
4.9%
82
4.7%
89
5.5%
107
7.0%
107
7.3%
1464
75.3%
1584
77.9%
1523
76%
1344
77.3%
1314
81.6%
1140
73.5%
1013
69.1%
1944
2033
2003
1739
1610
1552
1465
own-initiative
proceedings
66
3.5%
82
4%
75
3.7%
72
4.1%
52
3.2%
92
5.9%
84
5.7%
33
49
42
53
44
49
60
inspection
visits
2. Opinions of the Chancellor of Justice
Resolving petitions received by the Chancellor takes place according to the principle of freedom
of form and expediency of proceedings, and by taking necessary investigative measures to
ensure effective and independent investigation. The Chancellor’s opinion upon closing a case
shows what solutions the Chancellor found or what steps he took as a result of the proceedings.
2.1. Review of constitutionality and legality of legislation of general application
In 2014, the Chancellor opened 151 cases to review the constitutionality and legality of
legislation of general application, which makes up 10.3% of the total number of cases and
33.4% of the total number of substantive proceedings of cases. Of these, 140 were opened on
the basis of petitions and 11 on own initiative.
Within constitutional review proceedings the following were scrutinised:
conformity of Acts with the Constitution (110 proceedings, of these 102 based on
petitions by individuals and 8 on own initiative);
78
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents