Psychological examinations within asylum procedures
Since June 2006 almost 300 asylum seekers were examined in
the MAPP project. Of this selected group, in 75% of the cases
mental health problems have been diagnosed, which surely
or most likely interfere with the applicant’s ability to render
a coherent and consistent account. These numbers show that
in this selected group of vulnerable asylum seekers – well
over one percent of the total amount of asylum requests in
that period – the mental health problems are serious enough
to take into account when interviewing and deciding on an
asylum request. In most cases the psychological assessment
resulted in these asylum seekers being sent to the “regular”
asylum procedure, where there is more time for interview and
decision-making.
In 2008, after a strong lobby of MAPP, the Dutch Council for
Legal Aid, supported by the members of the Care Full initiative
The Care Full initiative
The Care Full initiative, launched in 2006, aims
to improve refugee status determination procedures for victims of torture and ill-treatment by
encouraging authorities to take better account
of the psychological, socio-cultural and physical factors that inhibit asylum seekers from presenting a coherent and complete history of their
experiences. The initiative stresses the need for
a full examination, conducted in accordance
with guidelines set out in the Istanbul Protocol.
It argues that any medical or psychological conditions must be given proper weight within the
process of refugee status determination.
In 2006 the Care Full Initiative published Care
Full: Medico-legal reports and the Istanbul Protocol in asylum procedures, which included chap-
ters on the physical after-effects of torture and illtreatment; psychological and psychiatric factors
affecting the ability of asylum seekers to speak
about their experiences during the asylum procedure; an assessment of the use of medical reports
in the asylum procedures in ten European countries; the use of medical reports at the European
Court on Human Rights and by the Committee
Against Torture (CAT); and the use and impact
of the Istanbul Protocol in asylum procedures.
In early 2007 the initiative published a set of
Principles and Recommendations – distributed
to NGOs in Europe and endorsed by 35 organisations – to bring to the attention of politicians and
policy makers, both nationally and internationally, the need for medical and psychological examination in the asylum procedure.
The documents on Care Full can be found at:
http://www.pharos.nl/supernavigatie/english/383
Organisations are welcome to sign up to the Care Full Principles and Recommendations. Please
contact Erick Vloeberghs at e.vloeberghs@pharos.nl.
37
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents