CAT/C/UZB/CO/5
their liberty. The State party should also ensure that victims of such violations obtain
redress and compensation, including medical and psychosocial rehabilitation.
Torture, ill-treatment, arbitrary detention, intimidation and harassment of human
rights defenders and journalists
16.
The Committee welcomes the State party’s decision to release from detention a
substantial number of human rights defenders and journalists since September 2016,
including many individuals named in paragraph 8 of its previous concluding observations.
However, the Committee regrets the State party’s determination that all of the claims of
arbitrary detention, torture and ill-treatment raised by these individuals were
“unsubstantiated”, and that only one previously detained person named in the Committee’s
previous concluding observations has been exonerated of the charges brought against him.
17.
The Committee is concerned by allegations that human rights defenders and
journalists in Uzbekistan continue to face arbitrary detention, surveillance, harassment and
other measures aimed at deterring them from carrying out their work. The Committee notes
with concern the allegations it has received of human rights defenders and journalists being
involuntarily committed to psychiatric hospitals in order to prevent them from conducting
their work, including Elena Urlayeva in March 2017 and Nafosat Ollashukurova in
September 2019. It is also concerned at reports that previously detained human rights
defenders Agzam Turgunov, Azam Farmonov and Dilmurod Saidov have been denied
permission to establish a non-governmental organization with the objective of petitioning
the authorities to investigate past allegations of torture and ill-treatment and to provide
redress to victims, and at reports that they have faced intimidation and harassment for
attempting to do so (arts. 4 and 12–16).
18.
The State party should:
(a)
Ensure that prompt, impartial and effective investigations are conducted
into all allegations of arbitrary deprivation of liberty, harassment and intimidation of
human rights defenders – including those named in paragraph 8 of the Committee’s
previous concluding observations – and journalists, and that officials found
responsible for such conduct are prosecuted;
(b)
Take measures to exonerate persons previously convicted of criminal
charges on the basis of evidence coerced through torture or following trials that did
not afford the defendants fundamental due process guarantees, ensure that victims
obtain redress, including compensation and rehabilitation, and consider creating an
independent commission tasked with looking into these matters;
(c)
Ensure that human rights defenders and journalists, including those
sharing information with United Nations human rights mechanisms, are able to work
safely and effectively in the State party, and review and revise laws and procedures
governing the registration and operation of non-governmental organizations in the
State party, ensuring they do not face reprisals;
(d)
Review the laws and procedures governing compulsory medical
treatment, including psychiatric confinement, and introduce safeguards to prevent its
misuse by the authorities.
The events in Andijan in 2005
19.
The Committee reiterates the serious concern expressed in paragraph 11 of its
previous concluding observations that the events of May 2005 in Andijan, which resulted in
hundreds of deaths, have not been the subject of impartial, effective investigations, despite
the State party’s acceptance of a recommendation during the universal periodic review in
2018 to establish recognition mechanisms for truth and compensation for the victims of the
events in Andijan and despite the recommendation made by former High Commissioner for
Human Rights Zeid Ra’ad al-Hussein during his 2018 visit to the State party to ensure that
victims would not be forgotten and that their grievances would be addressed (arts. 1, 4 and
12–16).
20.
The Committee reiterates its recommendation (CAT/C/UZB/CO/4, para. 11)
that the State party should take effective measures to institute an impartial, thorough
and effective investigation into the events of May 2005 in Andijan, and publish the
5