4
Working in challenging environments
– Egypt, Russian Federation, Ecuador
Raghda Sleit (El Nadeem Center, Egypt) introduced
the work of El Nadeem, which is the only rehabilitation
centre for torture victims in Egypt. The centre relies
on funding from private donors and is supported by
volunteer staff.
Faridun Zavurbekov (Interregional Non-governmental
Organization Committee Against Torture, Russian
Federation) introduced the work of CAT, which has
provided legal support and rehabilitation services to
victims of torture since 2000. The centre has set up
mobile groups in order to be able to react promptly to
allegations of human rights violations in any region of
the country. It then endeavours to organise an independent investigation into the incident and represents the victim at court and before investigation
bodies, as well as providing access to medical and
psychological treatment and counselling.
Yadira Narvaez (Fundación para la Rehabilitatión
Integral de Víctimas de Violencia, Ecuador) introduced the many challenges faced in providing rehabilitation services to torture victims in Ecuador. The
country has a high number of refugees, torture occurs
for more than half of persons in detention, and there
are high numbers of enforced disappearances. Only
0.8% of torture victims have received care directly
from the state. Many torture victims are reluctant to
accept assistance from the state as the state is generally the perpetrator of acts of torture. There are many
NGOs, around 12,000 working in the health field, but
only two centres provide torture rehabilitation services. PRIVA has been advocating for a holistic penal
code, which will recognise holistic rehabilitation
as an element of full reparation. It has entered into
dialogue with state institutions to encourage torture
victims’ rehabilitation to be included as a part of
public health policy. PRIVA seeks to influence university institutions to play a role in developing tools to
evaluate victims’ needs in order to generate changes
to public health policy. In this way knowledge is
spread amongst legal and health professionals, and
PRIVA is able to build on its limited capacity.
General discussion
Working in an environment in which the state authorities are not supportive of the work carried out by
rehabilitation centres was the common theme in this
workshop. Various countries, including Pakistan and
Sri Lanka gave examples of similar ways of working
to those illustrated in the three case studies. In some
16
International Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims
cases, trying to engage with the state authorities,
particularly by offering training for police, judiciary,
etc., can enable a more conducive working environment and build trust. It was also noted that breaking
down the stigma attached to torture is important to
encourage victims to rely on family support and seek
help from available services.
“”
The most important aspect of the workshop
was learning about different contextual
problems which will allow us to develop
strategies, especially to influence governmental institutions.
Yadira Narvaez, PRIVA, Ecuador
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents