National Preventive Mechanism
1.6 Reports of the commissions
The commissions view it as their duty to perform their work for the protection
of human rights as efficiently as possible. They aspire to select the right
priorities while taking the annual priorities of the NPM into consideration.
In order to uncover human rights violations and to prevent others from
occurring, they rely on all available information. To this end, an intensive
exchange of information with institutions and NGOs is particularly
important. The AOB’s redesigned website and more dynamic public relations
work is intended to support this exchange of information.
The following individual items from the commissions’ experience during
their visits should be emphasised:
Retirement and nursing
homes
Visits to retirement and nursing homes show that there are major differences
in the care standards – both quantitative and qualitative. The situation in
existing institutions and facilities differs greatly, even in those owned and
or run by the same legal entity. In some cases there is a significant need for
improvement with regard to the space situation, which sometimes results
in encroachment upon privacy. The majority of the employees expends a
great deal of effort and tries to act as professionally as possible, although
the cost pressure is significant. Generally the staffing ratio and the personnel
resources are not sufficiently directed toward the provision of psychosocial
care. In many institutions and facilities one gets the impression that people
are supposed to adjust to the system‘s uniform requirements instead of the
system being adjusted according to the often different needs of the people.
Thus, autonomous decisions (mealtimes, bedtimes, walks in the garden,
own room key, etc.) often cannot be made due to the daily routine with
early dinner and bedtime. Unfortunately, psychological supervision is rarely
taken advantage of. In the long run the mental health of the employees is
permanently impaired as a result and consequently that of the residents is
as well.
Youth welfare
It was found that many youth welfare facilities still suffer from a deficit of
systematic concepts for the prevention of violence and documentation. In
this area, psychological supervision has largely been established.
Institutions and
facilities for persons
with disabilities
The principle of inclusion and deinstitutionalisation formulated in the CRPD
requires major changes in the area of care of persons with disabilities. This
also of course applies to school enrolment of children with impairments. The
commissions find the continued existence of disability-specific large-scale
institutions to be highly worthy of censure.
Correctional institutions
In many places, health care in correctional institutions requires significant
improvement. This includes the disrespectful attitude of doctors and
care personnel that prisoners often complain about and the sometimes
unprofessional wording in medical documentation. The trial run of the
72
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents