SUPERVISION OF MONITORING AND SECURITY STAFF (OPINION)
terms of compliance with ethical rules,41 rising tensions among the
population held in custody, and in particular increasing recourse on
the part of the latter to auto- or hetero-aggressive violence, the fact
that this population includes a number of people who have completely
lost their way or lack any solid foundations, including psychological
reference points, means that it is a different, delicate and sometimes
very difficult task for the public sector employees responsible for
monitoring and security in such establishments to discharge the
missions entrusted to them, regardless of whether they work for the
police, the gendarmerie, the customs service or the prison authorities.
The relationships maintained with the competent authorities, the
themes raised by professional bodies and the confidential interviews
widely practiced by the contrôle général at the places it has inspected,
all highlight a number of issues causing suffering for employees at
work. This is something that is undeniable: it has internal consequences
for staff, in terms of the career choices they make, prompting them to
turn down jobs that are assumed to be uncomfortable or risky, and
gives rise to anxiety regarding a number of situations.
4/ Traditionally, such events are handled within the security services
in two ways: firstly via the line-management structure, which is
of course responsible for providing functional responses to such
difficulties; and secondly via the solidarity which, in the face of real
danger, binds together police officers, prison officers, customs
officers and gendarmes. It is not the place of the Contrôleur général
to pass judgement regarding the current effectiveness of these two
mechanisms. He cannot, nor does he wish to interfere in what is a
matter either for the responsible authorities or one that concerns how
staff work closely together.
5/ Nevertheless, in his view, in order to enhance the quality of the link
between working conditions and respect for human rights, the time
has come to go further and to systematically implement the practice
of supervision of civil servants and military personnel responsible for
monitoring and security missions. In his view, this is relevant to three
developments: a more general initiative being promoted right across
the civil service, as evidenced by the November 2009 agreement on
health and safety at work; to plans set out at ministerial level (e.g. the
41
N.B. decrees passed in 1986 and 2010 imposing a code of ethics on the French
police force and prison service respectively.
95
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents