3. Damage to health caused by imprisonment
A recent international comparative study examined prison suicide rates in 24 higher income countries,14
including four of those featured in our ten country study – England & Wales, Netherlands, Australia and
the United States of America (Fazel et al, 2017). This found no evidence to link high suicide rates with high
incarceration rates. In fact, the reverse was indicated, with the Nordic countries and the Netherlands having
some of the highest documented rates of prisoner suicide, yet the world’s lowest incarceration rates. By
contrast, rates of prisoner suicide in America and Australia were considerably lower, despite these countries’
higher incarceration rates. Nor was the higher number of prisoner suicides a reflection of more suicide
in the countries’ general populations. Instead, individual prisoner-level factors were considered the most
likely explanation for high suicide rates. These factors include the fact that prisoners in countries with lower
incarceration rates are statistically more likely to have committed serious violent crimes or have a mental illness,
both of which are associated with increased suicide risk (see also Fazel et al, 2008).
There is also evidence that recently released prisoners are at
even greater risk of suicide than serving prisoners, particularly
in the year after release (with this risk being higher still in the
first four weeks) (Pratt et al, 2006 and Spittal et al, 2014). In a
large-scale Swedish study, links were found between postrelease suicide and previous substance use disorder, relapse
into drug use, and homelessness (Haglund et al, 2014).
You have no reason to hope for a
brighter future, you’re done, you’re
oppressed, every ounce of you is
taken. So many women commit
suicide as soon as they’re released.
Female ex-prisoner 1, Kenya
3.1.7 Vulnerable sub-groups of prisoners
Being in prison carries greater health risks for some people as a result of their specific characteristics or
vulnerabilities or because of the prison’s inability to meet their health needs. When conditions are overcrowded
and prisons are under-resourced, the potential impact on their health may be even more serious. Reduced levels
of staff monitoring and intervention together with raised levels of tension and violence may leave them more
susceptible to abuse and they may find it more difficult to access treatment and support.
Female prisoners
Women in prison have frequently suffered physical, mental or sexual abuse and often have untreated health
problems (Moloney et al, 2009). Rates of mental illness are higher in female prisoners than male (Binswanger et
al, 2010). Women are likely to have histories of substance misuse and childcare issues and are at significantly
higher risk of self-harm and suicide in prison (Corston, 2007). Many of
the vulnerabilities documented in female prison populations mean that
I’d been abused before,
imprisonment does disproportionate and lasting harm, prompting calls for
and prison reawakened
greater community provision and for the abolition of female imprisonment
my past feelings of fear.
(for example Coles et al, 2018).
I walked into the prison
and felt just fear.
Female prisoners constitute a minority of incarcerated populations:15 around
7 per cent in Brazil, 10 per cent in the United States, 8 per cent in Australia,
Female ex-prisoner 2,
13 per cent in Thailand, 4 per cent in India, 3 per cent in African countries
Kenya
and 5 per cent in Western Europe (Walmsley, 2017). As most prison
systems have been designed to accommodate male prisoners, they are
rarely equipped to meet women’s specific needs. Health services for women in prison are sometimes minimal.
Standards of prison healthcare often fall below those of women’s health services in the community (World Health
Organization, 2011).
14 The data included suicides in pre-trial/remand detention as well as among sentenced populations: disaggregated prisoner suicide data
were not available.
15 Albeit a rapidly growing minority: see section 4.2.1 below. The percentages shown here have been rounded to the nearest whole
number.
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents