Towards a health-informed approach to penal reform? Evidence from ten countries
When we gave birth, the diet for us
and the babies was bad, there was
no special diet for us or the kids, and
this had a bad effect on our health.
Female ex-prisoner 4, Kenya
Even fewer prisons are equipped to meet the specific needs
of women who are pregnant or or have their babies in prison
with them (Macmadu et al, 2017). Imprisoned women who are
pregnant are a high-risk obstetric group and are more likely
to have a medical problem that could affect the pregnancy
outcome, yet are less likely to receive adequate antenatal care
(Knight et al, 2005).
Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) prisoners
LGBT people face heightened risks of violence, discrimination and abuse, with severe consequences for both
physical and mental health. Sexually transmitted infections are a further health concern since LGBT prisoners
are at higher risk of rape and assault in some countries (including when prison staff wrongly assume that sexual
conduct is consensual (Tarzwell, 2006)).
Transgender women are at high risk of violence in custody and experience greater health disparity (McCauley
& Brinkley-Rubinstein, 2017). Custody for transgender people is associated with reduced access to healthcare
and persistent mental and physical health problems – often reflecting the social marginalisation they experienced
prior to imprisonment. Transgender prisoners have specific health needs relating to ensuring (continued) access
to hormone therapy and other interventions required for transitioning. Access to suitably qualified healthcare
practitioners with an understanding of these needs is important but often lacking in prison settings.
Research on the experience of lesbian, gay and bisexual prisoners has mainly focused on the normalisation of
homophobia and suppression of gay male sexuality in hyper-masculine prison cultures (for example Jewkes,
2002). The proscription of sexual relationships in prison and the failure to supply condoms and adopt other harm
reduction approaches can heighten the risks of disease transmission through same-sex relationships.
Young prisoners
Children and young people in custody are likely to have experienced multiple levels of disadvantage and to have
deep-rooted and complex needs (Jacobson et al, 2010). The physical health of young people in custody tends
to be worse than that of their peers in the general population. They are also more likely than other young people
to have mental health problems, intellectual disabilities and substance use disorders. In a custodial setting, the
irritable mood that often accompanies depressive disorders in younger people can incite aggressive responses
in others, or result in self-harming behaviour. In America, an estimated 50 to 75 per cent of youths in contact
with the juvenile justice system meet criteria for a mental health disorder; and up to 80 per cent of incarcerated
juveniles may have at least one diagnosable mental health disorder (Grisso, 2008).
Older prisoners
Prisoners tend to experience age-related health problems at a rate equivalent to people a decade older in
the community. Accordingly, 50 year-old prisoners show the same signs of age-related infirmity and cognitive
decline as 60 year-olds in the general population (Baidawi et al,
2011). This could result from deprivation, stress and the numerous
Old and infirm patients were also
health disadvantages associated with imprisonment. Many of the
kept in jail hospitals. In Central
mental and physical health problems faced by older people are
Jail, Hisar II one of the admitted
exacerbated by factors typical of prison settings, including smokeprisoners was 114 years old.
filled environments, lack of exercise, poor diets, higher levels of
Commonwealth Human Rights
victimisation, and lack of social interaction and mental stimulation.
Initiative, India (idem)
Most prisons lack any form of geriatric healthcare service and do not
cater for the needs of older prisoners with health problems, rendering
them all the more vulnerable in custody (Potter et al, 2007).
Older prisoners typically suffer from chronic (often multiple) physical health problems. They are susceptible to
illnesses such as heart disease, diabetes, hypertension, cancer, hearing and vision impairment and a range of
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents