1.1 Obiski v zavodih za prestajanje kazni zapora in mladoletniškega zapora
1.1 Visit to prisons and juvenile prisons
ZPKZ Maribor – Oddelek Murska Sobota sodeluje z ZD Murska Sobota, iz katerega prihajata tudi zdravnica
in medicinska sestra, ki delata vsak torek (za obsojence, od 12. do 13. ure) in četrtek (za pripornike, od
12. do 13. ure). Ob četrtkih na oddelek prihaja psihiater (od 15. do 17. ure), ki ima z zdravstvenim domom
sklenjeno podjemno pogodbo. Na oddelek prihaja od štiri- do petkrat na teden medicinska sestra, ki
tudi pripravlja (po navodilu zdravnice ali psihiatra) predpisano terapijo, ki jo nato delijo pravosodni
policisti. Zobozdravstvene storitve se zaprtim osebam omogočajo v samem zdravstvenem domu.
Zaprtim osebam se omogoča nemoteno obiskovanje specialističnih pregledov v spremstvu pravosodnih
policistov, osebam, ki imajo že podeljene določene ugodnosti, pa se za pregled odobri namenski izhod.
Če zavodski zdravnik oceni, da določen pregled ni potreben, vendar ga oseba še vedno želi, ga mora kriti
sama, na kar se specialist tudi prej opozori. Obsojencem se zagotovi tudi zaupno testiranje na okužbo
s HIV in hepatitisom na podlagi drugega odstavka 63. člena ZIKS-1, za kar morajo le izraziti željo. Na
oddelku ni bolniške sobe; če bi jo oseba slučajno potrebovala, je ne premeščajo, temveč leži v svojem
dotedanjem ležišču. Do oprave obiska DPM je bilo opravljenih skupno 63 urinskih testov, ki se opravljajo
na podlagi sklepa strokovne službe, in sicer na podlagi terapevtskega dogovora (obsojenci, ki so vključeni
v obravnavo odvisnosti) in na podlagi soglasja (obsojenci, ki prestajajo kazen zaradi kaznivega dejanja,
povezanega s prepovedanimi drogami, a naj ne bi bili pod njihovim vplivom oziroma naj z njimi ne bi
imeli težav). V zvezi s tem je DPM UIKS zaprosil za stališče glede razlik v pristopih med zavodi (čas, ki
je na voljo za oddajo urina, možnosti glede stimuliranja uriniranja, ukrepi, ki sledijo morebitni neoddaji
urina zaradi zatrjevane nezmožnosti oddaje, razlage v smeri detekcijskega časa), saj gre za eno od
problematik, ki bi jo bilo treba celostno proučiti in pa vsaj v navedenih vidikih poenotiti prakso.
Na podlagi mnenja pogodbenega eksperta v zvezi s čakalnico pred ambulantnimi prostori ZPKZ Dob pri
Mirni ob našem obisku v tem zavodu v letu 2013 smo predlagali, naj bo ta opremljena z dvema vozičkoma,
enim za ležeči in enim za sedeči položaj pacienta, saj bolni ali poškodovani obsojenci ne morejo biti na
klopi kot preostali, ki niso v življenjsko nevarnem stanju. UIKS je bil mnenja, da je voziček medicinska
oprema in bi ga zato moral glede na medsebojni dogovor zagotoviti Zdravstveni dom Trebnje. Ker pa
je ta ob tem podal nasprotujoče si mnenje, smo obema predlagali, da se o implementaciji predloga
za zagotovitev vozička dogovorita. ZD Trebnje se je v letu 2014 odzval na predlog in sporočil, da so že
naročili voziček za sedeči položaj pacienta, meni pa, da glede na razpoložljivost nosil v zavodu ležeči
voziček ni potreben. UIKS je ob tem tudi napovedala, da je na pristojno Ministrstvo za zdravje podala
ponovno pobudo za medsebojno srečanje, kjer bi predstavila celostno problematiko, ki se pojavlja pri
opravljanju zdravstvene dejavnosti zaprtih oseb v ZPKZ. Verjame tudi, da bodo s skupnim sodelovanjem
našli ustrezne rešitve.
50
poročilo o izvajanju nalog DPM v letu 2014
DržavnI preventivnI mehanizEm po Opcijskem protokolu h Konvenciji OZN proti mučenju in drugim krutim, nečloveškim ali poniževalnim kaznim ali ravnanju
Murska Sobota Unit of Maribor Prison cooperated with Murska Sobota Community Health Centre, from
which a doctor and a nurse come who work on Tuesdays (for prisoners between 12:00 and 13:00) and
Thursdays (for detainees between 12:00 and 13:00). A psychiatrist, who has a work contract with the
community health centre, comes on Thursdays (between 15:00 and 17:00). A nurse visits the unit four
to five times a week and also prepares therapies prescribed by the doctor or the psychiatrist, which are
then distributed by judicial police officers. Dental services were provided in the community health centre.
Prisoners were enabled uninterrupted access to specialist examinations while being escorted by judicial
police officers. For persons already granted certain benefits, leave was approved for examinations. If
the prison doctor assessed that a certain examination was not necessary, but the person still wished
to undergo it, the person must cover the costs of any such examination, of which the specialist is also
notified. Prisoners were enabled confidential testing for HIV and hepatitis infection on the basis of
the second paragraph of Article 63 of the ZIKS-1, which the prisoners had to request. The unit has no
patient room; if required, a person was not transferred, but remained in their own bed. Until the NPM
visit, a total of 63 urine tests had been performed on the basis of a decision by the expert service,
i.e. on the basis of a therapeutic agreement (prisoners being treated for addiction) and on the basis
of consent (prisoners serving a sentence for a criminal offence connected with illicit drugs, but who
supposedly were not under their influence or were not addicted). In this regard, the NPM requested the
position of the Prison Administration of the Republic of Slovenia on different approaches to this matter
in prisons (time available for the provision of urine, options to stimulate urination, measures which
follow a possible failure to provide urine due to claiming the impossibility of provision, explanations
relating to detection times), since this is a problem requiring comprehensive consideration, or at least
the harmonisation of practice in the aforementioned aspects.
Based on the opinion of our contractual expert on the waiting room in front of the infirmary of Dob pri
Mirni Prison during our visit in 2013, we proposed that the waiting room be equipped with a wheelchair
for sitting and a mobile table for lying patients, since sick or injured prisoners cannot sit on the bench
like other patients who are not in a life-threatening situation. The Prison Administration of the Republic
of Slovenia believed that a wheelchair was medical equipment and should thus be provided by Trebnje
Community Health Centre as per the mutual agreement. However, the latter gave a contrary opinion,
so we suggested that both parties agree on the implementation of the proposal for providing the
wheelchair. In 2014, Trebnje Community Health Centre responded that a wheelchair for sitting patients
had already been ordered, but believed that a mobile table was not necessary, considering the availability
of stretchers in the prison. The Prison Administration of the Republic of Slovenia also stated that it had
resubmitted its initiative to the relevant Ministry of Health for a mutual meeting where problematic
areas established during the provision of medical care in prisons would be presented. It was certain that
suitable solutions would be found in mutual cooperation.
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE DUTIES AND POWERS OF THE NPM IN 2014
National Preventive Mechanism under the Optional Protocol to the UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment
51
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents