that establishment, in 2008. However, the
delegation did hear a number of graphic
and consistent accounts of deliberate
and routine physical ill-treatment of
newly admitted sentenced prisoners,
as well as several credible allegations of
physical ill-treatment by staf, including
senior ofcials, of inmates on disciplinary
segregation.
The CPT acknowledges that for many
years the Russian authorities have
made continued attempts to combat
overcrowding and improve material
conditions in pre-trial establishments.
Encouraging results were observed
during the 2012 visit and the Committee
recommends that the Russian authorities
pursue their eforts in this regard. The
Committee is also pleased to note that
steps are being taken to move away from
the system of large-capacity dormitories/
cells found in current establishments for
sentenced prisoners towards a system of
smaller living units. In this context, the
CPT reiterates its long-standing recommendation that the Russian authorities
formally amend the legislation in order
to align the minimum standard of living
space for sentenced prisoners with that
for remand prisoners. The Committee
also calls upon the Russian authorities
to ensure that eforts aimed at reducing
overcrowding and improving material
conditions in SIZOs and establishments
for sentenced prisoners go hand-in-hand
with the introduction of programmes of
structured out-of-cell activities.
As concerns prison health-care services,
the delegation was informed of a pilot
project, the main feature of which was
that prison health-care staf were no
longer administratively dependent on
the directors of the establishments in
which they were working. In this context,
the Committee reiterates that a greater
involvement of the Ministry of Health
in the provision of health-care services
in prison would help to ensure optimal
health care for prisoners.
88. In their response, the Russian
authorities refer to various issues raised
in the CPT’s report and provide detailed
updates on the legislative and organisational reforms of the law enforcement
agencies, the investigative authorities
and the prison system (including on the
implementation of plans to construct
new pre-trial establishments/units,
relocate SIZO No. 1 in Ufa and on the
improvement of prison health-care services). They also inform the Committee
of steps taken to prevent further ill-treatment of prisoners and persons in police
custody.
Report and response
published in December 2013,
CPT/Inf (2013) 41 and CPT/Inf (2013) 42
Report on the periodic
visit to the Slovak Republic
in September/October 2013
and response of the Slovak
authorities
(treatment of persons detained by the
police, situation of female and juvenile
prisoners, life-sentenced prisoners and
inmates held in high-security units)
89. The majority of the persons met by
the delegation who were or had recently
been detained by the police made no
complaints in respect of their treatment by police ofcers. Nevertheless,
the delegation did receive a number of
consistent and credible allegations of
physical ill-treatment by police ofcers
(including from several juveniles), consisting of slaps, punches and kicks to
various parts of the body. In addition,
some detained persons were purportedly
warned not to complain to their family or
a lawyer about the ill-treatment to which
Publication highlights
► Page 43
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents